Table VIII.
Statin AE | Relevant reports | Triangulating evidence and effect modification |
---|---|---|
Peripheral Neuropathy (PN)c |
- High-quality case control study using Danish databases.442 - Also, many case reports/case series.561-575 - Includes reports of multiple mononeuropathy.538, 576 - Reversibility is not complete in all cases, inferable from some case reports; from rate in former relative to current statin users442 and shown in Australian Adverse Drug Reaction Advisory Committee report.561 |
- Hypo–lipoproteinemia is linked to PN.577-581 - Cholesterol transports antioxidants essential to protection against PN.539-542 - We also observe that statins impair mitochondrial function, and impaired mitochondrial function has been linked to PN.543, 544 |
Sexual Dysfunctionc | Numerous case reports, case series, including several from European and Australian AE databases.444, 545-555, 582, 583 |
- Cholesterol is the biochemical precursor to testosterone. - Experimental and RCT evidence shows that statins reduce testosterone in men, though the average effect is modest.15, 369, 558 (Studies in small samples and /or with lower statin doses do not show a significant change in testosterone on average.) Clinical data showing testosterone reductions complement in vitro studies demonstrating statin effects on human testicular testosterone synthesis;584 and animal studies demonstrating statin effects on morphology and function of Leydig cells.559 - Mitochondrial dysfunction associated with gonadal dysfunction560 – of potential relevance given statin effects on mitochondrial function. - Oxidative stress associated with gonadal dysfunction585 – of potential relevance given adverse statin effects on oxidation in some.51, 52 - Testicular morphologic changes occurred in an animal study of high-dose statins, in which it was stated that testicular tissue (in dogs) was “the only organ for which a comparably low margin of safety was observed.”586 - Note that statins have also been reported to improve erectile function587 and the sexual benefits of sildenafil (Viagra™) in some subjects through endothelial function benefits,588-590 which may rely on the antioxidant effects of statins591-593 that predominate over pro-oxidant effects in many.51 |
Male Endocrine, Otherc |
- Gynecomastia: several reports of gynecomastia associated with statins.594-596 Statin use in organ transplant recipients was associated with increased risk of gynecomastia (statin use in 83.3% of those with gynecomastia, 39.6% of those without, p=0.041).597 - Oligospermia.556 - Questions have been raised about male infertility with statins.557 - Testicular pain: Case report.598 |
See above, “Sexual dysfunction.” |
Thyroid Dysfunction | See discussion in Table IV under ‘Thyroid disorders.’ |
|
Renalc | - Renal tubule toxicity.599 - Proteinuria: statins, particularly, high-dose statins, have led to proteinuria and hematuria.180, 600 - Statins have led to renal failure and death from renal failure in the context of rhabdomyolysis.82, 98-100, 102-104, 110, 202, 219, 247, 308, 419, 431, 601-605 |
- Statins have been reported, in an observational study, to be associated with less contrast nephropathy.606 This could reflect that statins signal higher lipids (and fat-soluble antioxidant transport) – i.e. indication bias, or could result from antioxidant effects of statins (antioxidants have been reported to reduce contrast nephropathy). - Statins have reduced proteinuria in some groups on average but may not do so in other groups (meta-analysis of RCTs – proteinuria was not reduced, e.g. in diabetes mellitus or hypertension).607, 608 Moreover, statins have been reported to increase proteinuria in some.180 In one study, statin use (compared with placebo) was associated with lower creatinine,609 which was presumed to reflect better kidney function.609 However, because muscle mass correlates with creatinine, and statins can reduce muscle mass, it is unclear the extent to which the creatinine reduction was driven by benefit to the kidney versus harm to the muscle (subclinical muscle wasting).60 |
Irritability/Aggression / Behavior Changec |
- Case series of severe irritability and/or aggression reproducibly arising on statins,443 also in pharmacovigilance database.467 - Observational study showing women on statins are more aggressive.610 |
- Low cholesterol linked to conduct disorder, violent antisocial personality disorder, and violent crime prospectively; to violent death in numerous observational studies; and in animal studies to aggression.611-623 - Several meta-analyses of prestatin cholesterol-lowering RCTs (including those with the most appropriate inclusion/exclusion criteria624, 625) showed significant increases in violent death.611 Statin meta-analysis has not.626 - Elucidated potential mechanisms include low central serotonin486, 611 and altered omega-3 to omega-6 ratios.17 Here, we add the suggestion of impaired cell energetics and oxidative stress, which are associated with a number of other aggression- and irritability related exposures.127, 627-641 This offers the possibility that benefits may predominate in some persons through benefits to endothelial function/ flow and/or anti-inflammation, consistent with bidirectional effects suggested in an RCT.642 |
Pulmonary, Respiratory, Shortness of Breath (see also ‘Cardiac Function and Heart Failure’)c |
- Shortness of breath as a symptom in statin AEs (including reports of dyspnea as the presenting symptom of otherwise asymptomatic rhabdomyolysis,95 associated with lactic acidosis412). - Respiratory failure has accompanied statin rhabdomyolysis.98 The following have also been reported in association with statins:
|
- Cardiopulmonary function and respiratory exchange ratio are affected by statins.156, 157 - Mitochondrial (cellular) respiration is affected by statins (see section 5). - Statins accelerate aging effect on (rat) diaphragm mitochondrial cellular respiration426 – affecting the major muscle of breathing. - Myopathy arises with statins (see section 1): effective respiration relies on skeletal muscles such as the diaphragm. -Statin pulmonary restrictive disease occurs, and resembles amiodarone pulmonary disease647 compatible with common mitochondrial origin.282 - Statins lower cholesterol, which is the precursor to vitamin D, which is associated with protection against autoimmune diseases, including lupus. - See also ‘Cardiac function and heart failure.’ |
Cardiac Function and Heart Failurec |
- Heart failure, pulmonary edema, and cardiac muscle rhabdomyolysis have been reported in cases of statin rhabdomyolysis.91, 109, 111 - In an observational study, statins adversely affected cardiac diastolic function in a fashion that was partially reversed by coenzyme Q10.653 |
- The heart muscle, like other muscles, may be affected in myopathy. - Statins lower coenzyme Q10, while addition of coenzyme Q10 in RCTs has reduced hospitalizations for heart failure and pulmonary edema.654 - Statins reduce coenzyme Q10, and coenzyme Q10 reportedly improves diastolic function,655 which is strongly ATP dependent. Diastolic function has reportedly been reduced with statins, an effect reversed by coenzyme Q10653 (study prospective but not placebo-controlled). - Statins lead to average improvement in heart failure or left ventricular systolic function in some studies, including randomized trials.656, 657 |
Heart Rhythm Disturbance:c Heart Block, Atrial Fibrillation |
- Atrioventricular block with rhabdomyolysis reported.239 - Bradycardia including heart block in a range of US FDA reports (secured under the Freedom of Information Act dated 8-1-06). - Atrial fibrillation with statin use reported.658 |
- Statins lower coenzyme Q10, and coenzyme Q10 has reportedly reduced arrhythmia in a range of settings.659, 660 - Patients with atrial fibrillation show greater oxidative damage to atrial mitochondrial DNA than those without,661 consistent with a role for statin oxidative/antioxidant effects. - Statins have reportedly produced heart block.239 They have also produced lactic acidosis22, 411, 413 and hyperkalemia,209, 396 each of which have been linked to heart block.662, 663 - Heart block may arise because of the energy dependence of cell signaling (with mitochondrial impairments impeding these) or due to alterations in tissue excitability (due to change in pH etc.). Heart block has been induced in other settings in which mitochondrial dysfunction induced high lactate.395 - Low cholesterol, associated with lower transport of fat- soluble antioxidants, has been linked observationally to higher atrial fibrillation rates.664 - Statins have pro-oxidant and antioxidant, proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory effects, with each dominating in different persons (more commonly, antioxidant and anti-inflammatory at modest doses in clinical-trial-equivalent middle-aged men). Atrial fibrillation has been linked to oxidant and inflammatory mechanisms, and its protection to the reverse.665-669 - Statins have reduced arrhythmia/atrial fibrillation in a clinical trial setting;670 individual effects may depart from average effects. |
Hyperkalemia | See discussion under ‘Heart rhythm disturbance’ (immediately above). |
|
Weight Gainc | Observational study with high rate of weight gain in high-dose statin group.27 |
- Statins lead to dose-dependent reductions in coenzyme Q10.20, 21 - Coenzyme Q10 supplementation has reduced appetite in patients with hyperphagia,671 and also improved insulin sensitivity.672 |
Neurodegenerative Disease: Parkinson Disease, also ALS or ALS-like Syndromec |
Case reports673 and case series.144, 145 | - Statins reduce coenzyme Q10.20, 21 - Coenzyme Q10 protects against neurodegeneration in animal models; and retards progression of early Parkinson disease in humans.674-677 - Low LDL-C has been linked to increased risk of Parkinson disease.678 - Higher cholesterol has been linked to increased survival with ALS.679 - LDL-C transports (and statins reduce) key fat-soluble antioxidants;680 reduced antioxidant transport unfavorably affects redox state (and mitochondrial function), which has a role in neurodegeneration protection.681-684 - Statins may be selectively toxic to muscle satellite cells, the stem cells for muscle that have (finite) regenerative potential.685 This may impair recovery of muscle in some statin users who experience normal or increased muscle injury on statins. (However, this is based on in vitro study.) - Observational studies link lower but not higher potency statins with dramatically lower rates of neurodegeneration686-688 and have implied there is causality, although this is incompatible with findings from RCTs, and is more consistent with confounding, e.g. by education and indication. Confounding by education was a likely factor in the similar apparent association of HRT to lower Alzheimer disease rates, which similarly suggested vastly lower rates of dementia in users;689 however, in fact, significantly increased rates of dementia arose with HRT when compared to placebo in RCTs, i.e. when treatment and placebo groups were chosen to be otherwise similar.690, 691Confounding by indication356 is also a significant possibility given the protective association of higher LDL- C to lower Parkinson disease rates,678 and the use of LDL-C as a criterion for statin use.692 (That is, statin use is a proxy for higher LDL-C prior to and often despite statin treatment – except with the most potent statins.) - Authors of recent studies continued not to control for lipids,688, 693 despite prior criticisms355, 356 noting potential for indication bias in similar studies.687 A later study attributed the lesser benefit of the more potent atorvastatin to selective benefits by simvastatin – the less potent statin in that study (vs alternative explanations such as atorvastatin more effectively overcoming benefit of high LDL-C). However, in the same authors' prior study, simvastatin was the more potent statin, and the one with which statin “benefit” was lost.687 The author holds a patent on simvastatin for Alzheimer disease. - Findings are potentially consistent with confounding by indication for Parkinson disease (given the association of higher LDL-C with Parkinson disease protection, and the association of statins as a proxy for higher prior, perhaps lifelong, and often current LDL-C); and confounding by education (higher education is linked to lower rates of incident dementia, and also higher use of preventive healthcare).355, 356 - It merits additional note that pro-oxidant conditions may spawn physiologic adaptations that ramp up antioxidant access, which may include elevation of lipid levels to boost antioxidant delivery. Association of higher lipid levels to conditions679 may reflect protective adaptations rather than causal predisposition. See in-depth discussion of proposed mechanism for statin- associated neurodegeneration.145 |
Immune, Autoimmunec |
- Case series and reports of lupus-like syndrome, autoimmune hepatitis, dermatomyositis and other.67, 71, 72, 74, 475, 498, 502, 503, 506, 694-710 - See above (Table I) for case reports of Guillain Barre-like syndrome and myasthenia gravis on statins. |
- Cholesterol is the precursor to vitamin D. High levels of vitamin D are associated with lower autoimmune disease risk, which we propose as a possible mechanism.711-723 - Enthusiasm for trials of statins has been expressed in autoimmune diseases, particularly those with inflammatory components.724 |
Pancreatitisc | Case reports of statin-induced pancreatitis alone or associated with statin rhabdomyolysis or muscle pain;105, 725-739 including recurrent cases.726, 737, 740, 741 |
See also discussion in this table, in rows entitled ‘Gastrointestinal’ and ‘Immune, autoimmune.’ - A population-based case-control study using Danish databases reported the adjusted OR for acute pancreatitis “among ever, current, new and former users of statins” (respectively) were: 1.44 (95% CI 1.12-1.80), 1.26 (95% CI 0.96-1.64), 1.01 (95% CI 0.43-2.37), and 2.02 (95% CI 1.37-2.97).742 The authors suggest this may imply protection by statins. However, this conclusion does not follow from this study design. Former users may disproportionately include those who experienced statin AEs (statin ‘noncompliance’ is linked to statin AEs484) and attendant mitochondrial injury (arising with and contributing to statin use). Occurrence of pancreatitis accompanying statin rhabdomyolysis suggest causal mediation by shared mitochondrial effects of statins, which may persist after treatment is discontinued; and mitochondrial pathology has repeatedly been linked to acute, chronic, and recurrent pancreatitits.743-750 However, it is also possible that statins may, analogously to the case for muscle and kidney function, both protect from pancreatitis and conduce to it in different subjects (based on predominance, e.g. of statin antioxidant vs pro-oxidant effects). |
Liver Pathologyc | Case reports of statin hepatitis or hepatic dysfunction alone or associated with rhabdomyolysis: autoimmune hepatitis, cholestasis, cholestatic hepatitis, steatosis, viral- like hepatitis, microvesicular hepatitis, hepatic fibrosis, progression to cirrhosis.96, 107, 108, 172, 474, 475, 477-479, 481, 492-504, 506, 508, 512, 513, 751, 752 |
Includes documentation of hepatic failure necessitating liver transplant.753 |
MELAS, Lactic Acidosis, other Mitochondrial Syndromesc |
- Statin induced lactic acidosis as an AE.413 - ‘Unmasking’ of mitochondrial myopathy as an AE, reduced fatty oxidation. - Statin induced MELAS alone or associated with rhabdomyolysis.112, 411 |
See section 5 for discussion of mitochondrial effects of statins. |
Dermatologicc | - See also “Immune, autoimmune” (dermatomyositis, lupus and lupus-like reactions). - Actinic dermatitis (chronic).754, 755 - Acute generalized exanthematous pustulosis.756 - Alopecia.757-759 - Angioneurotic edema.760 - IgA bullous dermatosis.702 - Cheilitis.761 - Contact dermatitis.762, 763 - Dermatographism.764 - Drug eruption.765 - Eczema.766, 767 - Eosinophilic fasciitis.768 - Ichthyosis.769, 770 - Lichen planus pemphagoides.771 - Lichenoid drug eruption.772-775 - Photosensitivity/ Phototoxicity.776, 777 - Radiation recall.778 - Skin lesions.779 - Toxic epidermal necrolysis.780 - Urticaria (chronic).781 |
- Range of potential mechanisms: hypersensitivity, autoimmune, nutritional. - Cholesterol is important in skin barrier function.782-785 - Icthyosis and disorders of cornification have been reported with several lipid-lowering agents.769 - Statins were reported to possibly improve skin response to sodium lauryl sulfate in one experiment.786 - Statins have been theorized as potential treatments for a range of skin disorders.787 - Regression of vitiligo with high-dose simvastatin was reported in one case.788 |
Oral Cavity | - Dry mouth.537 - Bitterness.537 - Oral paresthesias or itching.537 - Cough.537 |
Oral symptoms were appraised in a study in which 26 patients (50-70 years of age) with hyperlipidemia on statins in a general practice were referred over a month for oral evaluation.537 Of these, 23 reported dry mouth, 15 oral itch or paresthesia, 14 bitterness, and 12 cough. A trial of 2 weeks off statins led to marked abatement or resolution in each of these symptoms in 74%, 87%, 93%, and 92%, respectively.537 |
Visionc | - Cataracts.789-791 - External ophthalmoplegia.792 - A case series of 256 pharmacovigilance reports of ptosis, diplopia, and ophthalmoplegia on statins included 62 positive dechallenge and 14 positive rechallenge reports.793 Reports include 23 instances of total ophthalmoplegia; 8 of ptosis alone and 18 of ptosis in concert with diplopia. |
- Lens opacity seen in animal studies (high-dose).586 These led to concerns about cataracts with statins, but cataracts have not been increased on average in small studies of humans.794-796 Cataracts are thought to be induced by oxidative stress;794, 797, 798 so statins' bi-directional effects on oxidation with effect modification may be operative. Cataracts have been described in mitochondrial cytopathy.797 - In a British study, the unadjusted OR linking any recorded statin exposure to cataract was 1.41 (95% CI 1.21-1.65). It was 1.04 (95% CI 0.89-1.23, p=0.6) after “adjustment for consultation rate.”795 This is difficult to interpret: those seen more due to lipid therapy could have better access to cataract diagnosis leading to incorrect inferences in absence of adjustment; however, such adjustment could also extinguish a true association, through collinearity. - In a US study, incidence of nuclear cataract was lower in statin users relative to nonusers controlling for age (OR 0.55; 95% CI 0.36-0.84).799 Five-year incidence of cortical cataract showed the opposite trend (OR 1.28; 95% CI 0.79- 2.08) but was not significant.799 Confounding is a major concern in such correlational studies, and associations observed may be different in magnitude and direction from true relationships. - Statins lower coenzymye Q10 and alter omega-3 to omega-6 balance;17 combination of coenzyme Q10 with omega-3 (and one other substance) reportedly reversed early age-related macular degeneration in an RCT.800 - External ophthalmoplegia has been widely described in mitochondrial disease,801-806 and has been linked to deficiencies of fat-soluble vitamins transported by cholesterol.807 |
Olfaction | Hyposmia.808 | Lipids transport carotenoids,809 the precursor to retinol (vitamin A), which is important in smell and has been used in treatment of anosmia.810-812 |
Hematologic and Bone Marrow, Including Hemorrhagicc |
- See ‘Hemorrhagic Stroke’ Table VII. - Ocular hemorrhage reported as a statin AE.813 - Hematuria (microscopic).110, 180 - Bone marrow toxicity among multiple-organ toxicity arising on statins.96, 173 - Thrombocytopenia.814 - Petechia, and thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura.815-822 - Hemolytic anemia.823 - Nonhemolytic anemia.96 |
- Statin use has been observationally linked to lower bleeding, possibly as a proxy for higher cholesterol (and vitamin K?) in studies not adjusted for lipids.824, 825 (In one, only long-term [not current] statin use was linked to this, and those patients started on statins in an earlier era had higher average lipids.825) - After percutaneous coronary intervention, acquired thrombocytopenia developed more frequently, assessed by multivariate analysis, in patients who had previous statin administration (OR 3.28; p=0.0002).814 - Statins reportedly have antithrombotic effects, inhibit platelet aggregation, decrease platelet activity, have anticoagulant activity, affect blood viscosity, RBC deformability, and ‘improve’ von Willebrand factor activity.826-829 - Erosions and hemorrhage in the gastrointestinal tract and the brain in animal studies (high-dose).586 - Hemorrhage in gall bladder and brain, erosions in large intestines in animal study.830 - Mitochondrial mechanisms have been linked to ineffective erythropoiesis.831 - Statins inhibit bone-marrow-derived dendritic cell maturation – in vitro.174 |
Hypotensionc | Hypotension and angioedema have been described in a case of an atorvastatin hypersensitivity reaction entailing shock and collapse – with recurrence of angioedema on rechallenge.760 |
Statins (simvastatin and pravastatin), compared to placebo, led on average to modest but significant reductions in systolic and diastolic blood pressure in an RCT. The effect extended to persons with blood pressure below the sample median.832 |
Gastrointestinal c | - Ulcerative colitis.833, 834 - Severe gastric ulceration (with abdominal pain).835 - Ileus in association with statin rhabdomyolysis.431 - Protein-losing enteropathy.836 - Gastrointestinal AEs were the most common AE class in an analysis of AEs from clinical trials;837 and were the second most common in a small study.26 - Patients who are noncompliant on statins are more likely to have AEs – e.g. gastrointestinal and neurologic.484 |
- Statins affect omega-3 to omega-6 ratio;17 omega-3s provisionally associated with reduced gastrointestinal inflammation.838 - Additionally, cholesterol is the precursor to vitamin D, which has been linked to protection against inflammatory bowel disease.712, 839, 840 - Mitochondrial dysfunction can produce gastrointestinal symptomatology.448, 841-844 |
Exercise Limitationc and Fatigue/Lack of Energy |
- See ‘Exercise limitations or exercise-induced muscle symptoms,’ Table I. - Fatigue without muscle pain on statins was reported and evaluated in three patients.845 All were found to have low serum coenzyme Q10. Coenzyme Q10 supplements conferred subjective benefit to energy and reduced fatigue with exertion.845 |
Combined statins and beta blockers affect perceived effort and cardiorespiratory function.59 |
Psychiatricc | - See also ‘Irritability/aggression/behavior change’ in this table and ‘Sleep’ in Table VII. - Reports of psychosis, depression, paranoia, anxiety, and personality change, to surveillance databases (including Scandinavian and New Zealand pharmacoviligance databases as well as our UCSD Statin Effects Study patient targeted statin AE surveillance database).444, 445, 467, 846 - One report described four cases of depression arising with initiation of pravastatin and reversing on discontinuation, including one case with “the likelihood of suicide.”446 |
Mitochondrial dysfunction can produce psychiatric symptoms.455, 456, 847-857 |
Headachec | - Headache.858, 859 - Migraine (altitude associated).860 - A case of yawning headache was described in a patient with statin-induced myopathy and neuropathy, but was not ascribed to statins.861 |
- Mitochondrial dysfunction is linked to migraines.862-867 - Migraine occurrence in migraineurs has been shown to be reduced with coenzyme Q10 in an RCT.868 |
Other | - Acid maltase deficiency.161 - Vasospasm after subarachnoid hemorrhage reported to be greater in statin users869 (possibly from statin withdrawal or indication bias, however). - Nasal obstruction and nasal polyps resolving with statin discontinuation; three cases reported.870 - Temperature dysregulationc, including hyperthermia.871-873 |
ALS = amyotrophic lateral sclerosis; CI = confidence interval; HRT = hormone-replacement therapy; LDL-C = low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; MELAS = Mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes; OR = odds ratio; RBC = red blood cells; RCT = randomized controlled trial; UCSD = University of California, San Diego.
List is not complete.
Also reported to our UCSD Statin Effects Study group.