Table 4.
Service | Clinic group | Home group | P value for permutation test |
---|---|---|---|
Leg ulcer treatment/year | 804.03 (535.92) | 681.04 (391.70) | 0.05 |
GP services/year | 18.33 (67.14) | 29.82 (102.62) | 0.31 |
Hospital services/year | 55.24 (319.71) | 152.22 (680.96) | 0.17 |
Total costs | 877.60 (674.30) | 863.09 (865.32) | 0.90 |
Total costs (with increased overheads for home visits)* | 877.60 | 913.89 | |
Total costs (with other treatments excluded from home visits costs)† | 877.60 | 788.17 | |
Total costs (with 10% increase in home visit costs)‡ | 877.60 | 931.19 | |
Total costs (with 10% reduction in home visit costs)‡ | 877.60 | 794.98 | |
Total costs (with 10% increase in clinic attendance costs)‡ | 958.00 | 863.09 | |
Total costs (with 10% reduction in clinic attendance costs)‡ | 797.20 | 863.09 |
In baseline analysis no overheads were attributable to home visits as new working practices meant they were expected to be small. Overheads from other work,18 believed to be much greater than for nurses in this study, were used to estimate costs.
Other treatments are sometimes given within home visits. To estimate cost of this work non-treatment time was excluded from home treatment costs.
Mean cost estimates for home and clinic visits may be systematically biased because of missing data. Possible effects of any bias investigated by adjustment of visit costs by +/−10%.