Table 2.
Study | Random method | Allocation concealment | Blind method | Lost or exit | Quality assessment | Inclusion/exclusion criteria | Outcome measurement |
Miele et al[13], 2009 | Right | Right | Double blind | Yes, use ITT analysis | A | Both | CAI by Lichtiger; EI score; HI score |
Sood et al[12], 2009 | Right | Right | Double blind | Yes, use ITT analysis | A | Both | DAI by Sutherland |
Henker et al[15], 2008 | Right | Non-described | Non-described | No | B | Inclusion criteria | CAI by Rachmilewitz |
Zocco et al[20], 2006 | Right | Non-described | Non-described | No | B | Both | CAI by Rachmilewitz; EI by Baron; HI by Truelove-Richard |
Matthes et al[11], 2006 | Right | Not used | Double blind | Yes, use ITT analysis | C | Not mentioned | DAI by Sutherland |
Furrie et al[9], 2005 | Right | Non-described | Double blind | No | B | Inclusion criteria | CAI by Walmsley; SI by Baron |
Tursi et al[8], 2004 | Right | Non-described | Non-described | Yes, use ITT analysis | B | Both | CAI by Lennard; EI score; HI score |
Kruis et al[18], 2004 | Right | Right | Double blind | Yes, use ITT analysis | A | Both | Scores according to Rachmilewitz |
Kato et al[10], 2004 | Right | Non-described | Non-described | No | B | Both | CAI by Lichtiger; EI by Harig, Scheppach; HI by Matts |
Cui et al[16], 2004 | Right | Not used | Non-described | No | C | Not mentioned | Not mentioned |
Ishikawa et al[17], 2003 | Right | Non-described | Non-described | No | B | Inclusion criteria | Exacerbation of clinical symptoms |
Rembacken et al[14], 1999 | Right | Non-described | Double blind | Yes, use ITT analysis | B | Inclusion criteria | Scores according to Rachmilewitz |
Kruis et al[19], 1997 | Right | Non-described | Double blind | Yes, use ITT analysis | B | Both | The same of the CAI score under the E. coli and mesalazine; Scores according to Rachmilewitz |
CAI: Clinical activity index; SI: Sigmoidoscopy index; EI: Endoscopy; HI: Histology index.