Table 1.
Study/country | E1 | M2 | Q3 | Outcome measures | Cohen's | d4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
School setting | ||||||
Haerens et al. (2007) [12], Belgium | N | N | 3 | Total PA level (min/day) | -0.01 | |
School-related PA (min/day) | 0.14 | |||||
Leisure time sport (min/day) | -0.09 | |||||
Leisure time active transportation (min/day) | 0.05 | |||||
Verstraete et al. (2006) [13], Belgium | Y | N | 2 | Low intensity PA (% time spent during morning recess) | -0.30 | * |
Moderate intensity PA (% time spent during morning recess) | 0.53 | ** | ||||
Vigorous intensity PA (% time spent during morning recess) | -0.12 | |||||
Moderate to vigorous PA (% time spent during morning recess) | 0.35 | * | ||||
Low intensity PA (% time spent during lunch break) | -1.06 | *** | ||||
Moderate intensity PA (% time spent during lunch break) | 0.89 | *** | ||||
Vigorous intensity PA (% time spent during lunch break) | 0.54 | ** | ||||
Moderate to vigorous PA (% time spent during lunch break) | 1.00 | *** | ||||
Hill et al. (2007) [11], UK | N | N | 2 | Exercise sessions min. 30 min/week without PE (leaflet only) | 0.18 | |
Exercise sessions min. 30 min/week without PE (leaflet plus quiz) | 0.45 | * | ||||
Exercise sessions min. 30 min/week without PE (leaflet + implementation intention prompt) | 0.32 | * | ||||
Tsorbatzoudis (2005) [14], Greece | N | N | 2 | End of intervention: exercise habits (score) | 0.59 | ** |
Lubans and Sylva (2006) [15], UK | N | N | 1 | End of intervention: moderate to vigorous PA (min/week) of 20 min. or longer | 0.65 | * |
Murphy et al. (2006) [16], Ireland | Y | N | 1 | x | ||
Lindberg et al. (2006) [17], Sweden | N | Y | 1 | x | ||
Chatzisarantis and Hagger (2005) [18], UK | N | N | 1 | Frequency of mild, moderate and vigorous PA during leisure time in the last 5 weeks | 0.08 | |
Digelidis et al. (2003) [19], Greece | Y | Y | 1 | End of intervention: frequency of regular exercise in the previous month | -0.04 | |
School setting with involvement of family | ||||||
Harrison et al. (2006) [20], Ireland | Y | N | 3 | Moderate to vigorous PA: principal PA + intensity (30 min blocks/day) | 2.07 | **** |
Haerens et al. (2007) [21], Belgium | Y | N | 2 | Total PA level (min/day) | 0.12 | |
School-related PA (min/day) | 0.39 | * | ||||
Leisure time sport (min/day) | -0.02 | |||||
Leisure time active transportation (min/day) | 0.07 | |||||
Subsample accelerometer data: PA of light intensity (min/day) | 0.53 | ** | ||||
Subsample accelerometer data: PA of moderate to vigorous intensity (min/day) | 0.50 | ** | ||||
Christodoulos et al. (2006) [10], Greece | Y | N | 2 | Organised moderate to vigorous PA (h/week) | 3.53 | **** |
Total moderate to vigorous PA (h/week) | 2.79 | **** | ||||
School setting with involvement of family and community | ||||||
Simon et al. (2006) [22], France | Y | N | 2 | Leisure supervised PA (%) | 0.56 | ** |
Jurg et al. (2006) [23], The Netherlands | Y | N | 1 | Total PA score (min/day at least moderately active) | 0.11 | |
Meeting the guidelines: 60 min/day of moderate PA (%) | 0.27 | * | ||||
Moon et al. (1999) [24], UK | Y | Y | 1 | Taking part in sports at school (not PE) once or more a week (%) | -0.02 | |
Community with involvement of schools | ||||||
Baxter et al. (1997) [25], UK | Y | Y | 2 | Students that exercise 3 or more times weekly (%) | 0.40 | * |
Primary care | ||||||
Ortega-Sanchez et al. (2004) [26], Spain | N | N | 1 | 6 months after 1st session: duration (min/week) | 0.28 | * |
6 months after 1st session: frequency (days/week) | 0.17 | |||||
6 months after 1st session: intensity in points (mild = 1, moderate = 2, vigorous = 3) | 0.32 | * | ||||
12 months after 1st session: duration (min/week) | 0.37 | * | ||||
12 months after 1st session: frequency (days/week) | 0.25 | * | ||||
12 months after 1st session: intensity in points (mild = 1, moderate = 2, vigorous = 3) | 0.44 | * | ||||
Walker et al. (1999) [27], UK | N | Y | 1 | Teenagers who reported positive behaviour change (% 3 months after intervention) | 0.14 | |
Kelleher et al. (1999) [28], Ireland | N | Y | 1 | Exercise (times/week) by 12-15 years old | < 0.01 | |
Individual | ||||||
Woods et al. (2002) [29], Scotland | N | N | 2 | Membership of the Sport and Recreation Service at the university (%) | 0.61 | ** |
1Intervention includes environmental components: Y(es)/N(o)
2Intervention aims to affect more health behaviours besides physical activity: Y(es)/N(o)
3Global rating quality assessment: three-grade scale (3 = strong; 2 = moderate; 1 = weak)
4Classification of effect sizes: trivial (Cohen's d ≤ .2); * small (Cohen's d > .2); ** moderate (Cohen's d > .5); *** large (Cohen's d > .8); **** very large (Cohen's d > 1.3)
xImpossible to calculate effect size based on reported results