Table 1.
Enzyme/class | PDLD/S-LRA/β | LRA/β | LIE | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
εp = 4 (εp = 20) β=0.25 (default) | εp = 4 (εp = 20) (fitting) | Fast version ε p = 4 (ε p = 20) β=0.25 (default) | εp = 1 β=0.25 (default) | εp = 1 (fitting) | εp = 1 β=0.25 (default) | εp = 1 (fitting) | ||
Chorismate mutase (Isomerase)103 | β=0.30 | β=0.50 | β=0.51 | |||||
1* | −15.50 (−8.68) | −15.99 (−9.17) | −15.53 (−8.59) | −8.15 | −8.39 | −6.16 | −7.32 | −8.30 |
2* | −15.44 (−8.80) | −15.87 (−9.23) | −19.65 (−12.76) | −8.74 | −9.00 | −8.47 | −9.07 | −9.00 |
3* | −4.94 (−4.66) | −5.11 (−4.83) | −5.20 (−4.52) | −5.22 | −3.92 | −5.11 | −4.74 | −5.00 |
Thrombin (Hydrolase)82 | β=0.30 | β=0.35 | β=0.41 | |||||
4* | −8.67 (−9.99) | −10.26 (−11.59) | −8.99 (−10.21) | −12.85 | −11.55 | −10.06 | −11.55 | −11.42 |
5* | −9.46 (−10.06) | −11.29 (−11.89) | −9.20 (−9.72) | −9.09 | −9.99 | −6.58 | −9.47 | −11.41 |
Trypsin (Hydrolase)82 | β=0.26 | β=0.35 | β=0.45 | |||||
6* | −8.35 (−7.77) | −8.56 (−7.98) | −9.01 (−8.62) | −9.37 | −8.24 | −7.27 | −8.62 | −8.69 |
7* | −10.39 (−9.94) | −10.56 (−10.11) | −10.42 (−9.32) | −10.72 | −9.37 | −9.59 | −9.15 | −9.75 |
8* | −10.68 (−10.49) | −10.93 (−10.74) | −10.84 (−9.98) | −10.97 | −9.56 | −11.55 | −11.57 | −10.20 |
Renin (Aspartyl protease)104 | β=0.22 | β=0.40 | β=0.53 | |||||
9 | −9.55 | −9.12 | −9.19 | −10.16 | −9.44 | −9.76 | −9.75 | −9.78 |
10 | −10.28 | −9.72 | −9.98 | −9.56 | −9.07 | −9.50 | −9.41 | −9.77 |
11 | −8.64 | −8.15 | −8.50 | −8.15 | −7.71 | −7.23 | −8.72 | −7.50 |
HIV Protease (Aspartyl protease)105 | β=0.25 | β=0.51 | β=0.64 | |||||
12 | −10.34 | −10.34 | −8.69 | −10.88 | −10.40 | −6.89 | −10.39 | −10.40 |
Aldose Reductase (Oxidoreductase)106 | β=0.30 | β=0.25 | β=0.25 | |||||
13* | −8.69 (−7.12) | −9.91 (−8.34) | −6.70 (−5.50) | −8.30 | −8.30 | −8.32 | −8.32 | −8.46 |
Trypsin (Hydrolase)107 | β=0.30 | β=0.60 | β=0.80 | |||||
14* | −3.24 (−4.16 ) | −3.76 (−4.68) | −3.37 (−4.43) | −6.46 | −6.23 | −4.34 | −6.00 | −6.35 |
T4 lysozyme (Hydrolase) 83,93,108 | β=0.33 | β=0.80 | β=0.80 | |||||
15 | −4.34 | −5.08 | −2.92 | −3.23 | −4.50 | −3.16 | −4.40 | −5.19 |
All binding free energies are in kcal/mol.
All charged ligands have been denoted by ‘*’. Note that ‘α’ denotes the electrostatic term in our study while it represents the non-electrostatic β term in studies by Åqvist and coworkers13,42 In the PDLD/S-LRA/β studies, the first column corresponds to the calculations where the protein groups are ionized with εp = 4, and εp = 20, the second column provides fitted values for column 1 and the third column corresponds to the fast version described in the main text. (For details, see Table S1 and S2; supporting information).