Skip to main content
. 2010 Apr 16;7(4):1720–1743. doi: 10.3390/ijerph7041720

Table 2.

Summary of reviews and meta-analyses for weight changes.

Review/Meta-Analysis Year Number of Articles Percentage Effect Size

Physical Activity

Amorim et al. [50] 2007 1 N/A 0.00
Conn et al.a [36] 2009 13 N/A 0.07
Kavookjian et al.a [41] 2007 4 100% N/A
7 (BMI) 43% (BMI)
Shaw et al. [51] 2006 2 N/A 0.58

Dietary Behaviours

Amorim et al. [50] 2007 1 N/A 5.76
Brunner et al.a [52] 2007 21 38% N/A
Hooper et al. [56] 2004 5 60% N/A
Povey et al.a [54] 2007 6 17% N/A
5 (BMI) 40%
Rolls et al.a [55] 2004 16 44% N/A
Rooney et al. [57] 2007 4 50% N/A

Physical Activity and Diet

Amorim et al. [50] 2007 4 N/A 1.79i
1 −0.49ii
Blue & Blacka [58] 2005 11 73%i N/A
Chaston et al. [65] 2007 3 100%ii N/A
Curioni et al. [59] 2005 6 N/A 0.2ii
Hawthorne et al. [60] 2008 3 (BMI) 0% i (BMI) 0.31 i (BMI)
Ketola et al. [66] 2000 17 71% i N/A
Neville et al.a [44] 2009 6 50% i N/A
Nield et al. [61] 2007 4 100%ii 0.51ii
Norris et al. [63] 2005 9 83% i 0.77i (7 studies)
6 (BMI) 67% i (BMI) 0.97i (BMI)
Norris et al. [62] 2005b 8 N/A 0.01i
Orozco et al. [64] 2008 7 N/A 0.66i
6 (BMI) 0.57i (BMI)
Povey et al.a [54] 2007 6 33%i N/A
Sharmaa [33] 2007 8 88%i N/A
4 (BMI) 75%i (BMI)
Shaw et al. [51] 2006 15 N/A 0.48ii
6 (BMI) 0.21ii (BMI)

Note: N/A = Not applicable as either an effect size was not calculated or a percentage could not be extracted. PA = physical activity. BMI = Body Mass Index.

a

Review/Meta-analysis was used in overall objective (i.e., behavioral outcome).

i

Diet and physical activity group versus control group.

ii

Diet and physical activity group versus diet only group.