Table.
Characteristics of included studies. All studies were double blind, double dummy,* parallel group, randomised controlled trials except where indicated
Study | No of participants with seasonal allergic rhinitis | Age range (mean age) | Interventions | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Munch10 | 61 | 16-56 (29) | Budesonide 400 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Dexchlorpheniramine 12 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Beswick11 | 49 | 14-64 (28) | Beclomethasone 400 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Terfenadine 120 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Global rating | ||||
Wood12 | 74 | 12-75 (28) | Beclomethasone 400 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Astemizole 10 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Lancer13 | 18 | Not reported | Beclomethasone 400 μg | Global rating |
Terfenadine 120 mg | Nasal resistance | |||
Juniper14 | 90 | 18-70 (41) | Beclomethasone 400 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Astemizole 10 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Robinson†15 | 20 | 15-58 (31) | Beclomethasone 400 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Terfenadine 120 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Bunnag16 | 69‡ | 16-70 (30) | Budesonide 200 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Astemizole 10 mg | ||||
Darnell17 | 214 | 13-69 (28) | Fluticasone 200 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Terfenadine 120 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Global rating | ||||
Simpson18 | 143 | >15 (27) | Budesonide 400 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Terfenadine 120 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Van Bavel19 | 232 | >12 (40) | Fluticasone 200 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Terfenadine 120 mg | Global rating | |||
Schoenwetter20 | 298 | >12 (31) | Triamcinolone 220 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Loratadine 10 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Bernstein21 | 239 | Adults (36) | Triamcinolone 220 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Astemizole 10 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Global rating | ||||
Bronsky22 | 348 | >12 (30) | Fluticasone 200 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Terfenadine 120 mg | Global rating | |||
Nasal resistance | ||||
Brooks23 | 60 | Not reported | Beclomethasone 336 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Loratadine 10 mg | Eye symptoms | |||
Global rating | ||||
Géhanno24 | 114 | 13-80 (39) | Fluticasone 200 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Loratadine 10 mg | Global rating | |||
Vervloet25 | 238 | 12-75 (29) | Fluticasone 200 μg | Nasal symptoms |
Cetirizine 10 mg |
All patients took tablets and used nasal sprays, but only one preparation was active.
Double blind double dummy crossover randomised controlled trial.
Participants had perennial allergic rhinitis.