Skip to main content
. 2010 May 25;7(5):e1000273. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000273

Table 4. Reasons for removal of items in the consensus meeting within each domain of development.

Domain of Development Items Removed Reason for Removal
Gross motor Head erect continuously when sat up or held Age range for item exactly the same as another item
Stands alone for a few seconds Age range for item exactly the same as another item
Walks backwards Poor fita. Reported as “difficult to get children to do this.”
Jumps with both feet off the ground Age range for item exactly the same as another item
Jumps over rope 10 cm off ground Age range for item exactly the same as another item that involves jumping
Throws one or more balls into a basket (out of five) Poor interobserver and intra-observer reliability and poor fit (difficult to be consistent with item)
Carries a cup on head with no hands Sex specific, girl's task
Fine motor Plays with cup and spoon in purposeful manner Age range for item exactly the same as another item
Tower of blocks up to eight blocks Poor fit and age range exactly same as other item
Can do “Sharp” (put thumb up in specific way) Sex specific, boy's item.
Is able to play Chipapa (clapping game) Sex specific, girl's item.
Able to fold paper in two halves Not achieving 90% by 7 y. Found difficult for children to do by examiners.
Makes a bridge with six bricks Poor reliability. Not achieving 90% by 7 y
Makes stairs with bricks Poor reliability. Not achieving 90% by 7 y
Copies row of bottle tops Poor reliability. Not achieving 90% by 7 y
Copies square pattern of bottle tops Poor reliability. Not achieving 90% by 7 y
Language Says four or more words Poor fit. Not easy to be so exact.
Says eight or more words Poor fit. Not easy to be so exact.
Identifies at least two objects Poor fit.
Uses many words >20 Poor fit
Points to body parts: at least 1 body part Age range for item exactly same as another item
Names two objects Poor fit.
Knows his or her father's last name Poor fit. Subjectively many children don't know father's last name
Copies two lines of song well at home Poor fit. Subjectively not clear item
Number recall 1–4 Poor fit and age range same as another item
Knows quantities Poor reliability
Sings two lines of song clearly Poor fit and many missing
Retells stories in brief manner Poor fit and few achieving before 7 y
Knows how old they are Poor reliability. 90th centile not before 8 y
Knows materials Not achieving 90th centile by 7 y.
Social Drinks from a cup but may spill some Unclear question. Poor fit. Some normal children failing
Wants to be escorted to pit latrine/toilet Unclear what toilet is. Poor fit and reliability
Able to imitate household chores Poor logistic regression. Sex specific, girl's task
Can do errands e.g., bring salt Poor logistic regression. Sex specific, girl's task
Able to play singing games Sex specific, girl's task.
Plays Masanje/house Sex specific, girl's task.
Spends more time with specific friend Sex specific (boy's task) and poor fit
Does housework properly useful round house Not achieved by 7 y
Knows how to take responsibility without being asked Not achieved by 7 y
a

Poor goodness of fit in logistic regression.