Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 Aug 1.
Published in final edited form as: Ann Epidemiol. 2009 Apr 25;19(8):531–538. doi: 10.1016/j.annepidem.2009.03.011

TABLE 2.

Reasons, and their subcomponents, underlying maternal decisions about vaccinating their daughters against HPV

Vaccine declined (N = 19) Vaccine received (N = 33)
1 Perceived risk of infection
n = 7 n = 9
 Not likely to become/not already sexually active  Likely to become/is already sexually active
 No family history of cancer  HPV highly prevalent in society
 Cervical cancer is not deadly.  Cannot tell which partners harbor HPV
 HPV is not very contagious.  Never know when adolescents will start having sex
 Daughter taught the “right thing to do,” so risk is low.  Family history of cancer (general)
2 Age-related
n = 7 n = 0
 Too young for a vaccine against an STD
 Want to wait till daughter is older
 Vaccination in general can be harmful to a preadolescent.
3 Knowledge
n = 6 n = 1
 Need more personal information about HPV/vaccine  Wish there were a lot of “data” about the vaccine's long-term effectiveness
 Medical establishment needs to know more about HPV/vaccine.
4 Vaccine safety
n = 8 n = 7
 Not enough data on long-term safety of vaccine  Vaccine is “too new” to feel completely comfortable with it.
 Vaccines (in general) linked to autism  Generally benefits to vaccination outweigh safety concerns.
 Many vaccines initially declared safe later found to be unsafe
5 Protection/prevention of illness and disease
n = 2 n = 26
 HPV vaccine will prevent illness. (general)  HPV vaccines are a general safeguard against illness/disease.
 Providing HPV vaccines before sexual activity would afford best protection.  HPV vaccines protect against HPV/cervical cancer.
6 Personal experience with HPV
n = 1 n = 12
 Mother had personal experience with abnormal exams.  Mother or family member had experience with cervical cancer/abnormal exams/HPV infection.
7 Physician recommendation
n = 2 n = 11
 Physician gave a reason to wait on vaccine.  Doctor recommended it, so daughter got it.
 Always follow doctor recommendations.
8 General beliefs about vaccination
n = 2 n = 5
 Problematic to get multiple vaccines at one time  Believe strongly that vaccines are beneficial
 Don't generally “like” vaccines  No big deal—just one more vaccine
9 Control over health-related decisions
n = 2 n = 4
 Want to wait until daughter can make her own decision about the vaccine  Want to get daughter vaccinated while mother can control medical decisions
 Daughter expressed opinion that she doesn't want the vaccine.  Daughter voiced a desire to get the vaccine.
10 Financial issues
n = 3 n = 2
 Wanted vaccine but could not get because of lack of/unsure of insurance coverage  Daughter was going to “age out” of insurance coverage for vaccine soon so wanted to get now.
 Would not have been able to get the vaccine if there had not been coverage
11 Religious values
n = 1 n = 0
 Religious values “played a role” in the decision.

STD = sexually transmitted disease.