TABLE II.
Characteristics of included studies
Study a | Caregiver |
Study group |
Control group (if applicable) |
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
(n) | Description | (n) | Description | ||
Randomized controlled trials | |||||
Bohnenkamp et al. 2004 20 | General oncology nurse | 14 | Age 18 years or older, able to read and write in English, have a permanent ostomy, have a working residence telephone line, randomly assigned to groups | 14 | Same as study group |
Non-randomized controlled studies | |||||
Allen et al. 1995 21, Allen and Hayes 1995 22, Allen and Hayes 1994 18 | Medical oncology physician | 39 | Oncology patients requiring consultation, weather would not permit oncologist to visit in person | 21 | Study patients seen subsequently in person |
Doolittle et al. 1997 23 | Medical oncology physician | 103 | Patients referred for initial consultation, reassessment, or follow-up; group inclusion criteria not reported | 81 | Same as study group, group inclusion criteria not reported |
Phillips et al. 1998 24 | Dermatology physician | 51 | Patients respond to flyers advertising skin cancer screening sessions | 51 | Study patients seen subsequently in person |
Doolittle 2000 25, Whitten et al. 1998 26 | Palliative care physician | 50 | Inclusion criteria not reported | 50 | Inclusion criteria not reported |
Coelho et al. 2005 27 | Genetic counselling nurse | 18 | Referred to clinical genetics because of history of breast/ovarian or colon cancer, closer to vc site than in-person site | 21 | Closer to in-person site than vc site, otherwise same as study group |
Weinerman et al. 2005 10 | Medical oncology physician | 30 | Have gastrointestinal malignancy, live in the catchment area of Nanaimo Regional Hospital, have adequate vision and hearing, sequential referrals until 30 consenting patients | 30 | Same as study group |
Stalfors et al. 2005 11, Stalfors et al. 2003 28 | Otolaryngology physicians (group review) | 45 | Inclusion criteria not reported | 39 | Inclusion criteria not reported |
Case series | |||||
Kunkler et al. 1998 29 | Medical oncology physician | 8 | New patient referrals of follow-up appointments, located in Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary | — | Not available |
Gray et al. 2000 30 | Genetic counselling nurse | 8 | Family history of cancer | — | Not available |
Mair et al. 2000 31 | Medical oncology physician | 22 | Age older than 18 years, free of mental impairment, no hearing or other impairment that would render telephone conversation difficult | — | Not available |
Sezeur et al. 2001 32 | Medical oncology physician | 16 | Inclusion criteria not reported | — | Not available |
Doolittle et al. 2004 33 | Medical oncology physician | 121 | Inclusion criteria not reported | — | Not available |
Olver et al. 2005 34 | Palliative care nurse | 20 | Inclusion criteria not reported | — | Not available |
Laila et al. 2008 17 | Medical oncology physician | 6 | Receiving chemotherapy, age older than 18 years, life expectancy > 12 weeks, vital signs state, receiving specialist medical care from home | — | Not available |
Multiple studies at a single entry describe the same patient population.