Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 Jun 25.
Published in final edited form as: Cogn Behav Ther. 2009;38(1):29–41. doi: 10.1080/16506070902980745

Table 2.

Causality testing for each participant

Participant Condition Null hypothesis Parameter(s) constrained χ2 df p
1 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety φ421=0 9.66 1 .002
Anxiety −/→ worry φ412=0 4.81 1 .030
2 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety θ821=0 7.63 1 .010
Anxiety −/→ worry θ812=0 13.32 1 .000
3 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety φ121=0 10.30 1 .001
Anxiety −/→ worry θ312=0 11.92 1 .000
4 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety φ421=0 18.61 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry φ312=0 6.31 1 .010
5 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety φ1021=0 24.67 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry φ1012=0 14.28 1 .000
6 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety φ121=0 15.78 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry φ612=0 16.13 1 .000
7 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety ns
Anxiety −/→ worry ns
8 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety θ421=0 20.83 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry ns
9 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety φ921=0 5.98 1 .020
Anxiety −/→ worry θ112=0 13.84 1 .000
10 CBT Worry −/→ anxiety θ121=0 8.05 1 .004
Anxiety −/→ worry θ112=0 10.96 1 .000
11 AR Worry −/→ anxiety θ121=0 16.65 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry ns
12 AR Worry −/→ anxiety ns
Anxiety −/→ worry φ112=0 9.59 1 .002
13 AR Worry −/→ anxiety φ821=0 4.53 1 .030
Anxiety −/→ worry φ812=0 4.80 1 .030
14 AR Worry −/→ anxiety φ121=0 20.83 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry φ112=0 56.45 1 .000
15 AR Worry −/→ anxiety φ221=0 31.54 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry φ112=0 12.55 1 .000
16 AR Worry −/→ anxiety θ321=0 10.81 1 .001
Anxiety −/→ worry φ312=0 12.57 1 .000
17 AR Worry −/→ anxiety ns
Anxiety −/→ worry ns
18 AR Worry −/→ anxiety θ121=0 7.87 1 .005
Anxiety −/→ worry θ112=0 16.86 1 .000
19 AR Worry −/→ anxiety θ121=0 132.81 1 .000
Anxiety −/→ worry θ112=0 4.94 1 .030
20 AR Worry −/→ anxiety φ221=0 6.60 1 .010
Anxiety −/→ worry φ212=0 43.33 1 .000

Note. CBT=cognitive behavioural therapy; AR=applied relaxation; −/→=does not predict; φ=autoregressive parameter; θ=moving parameter; ns=a parameter that was not significant at any lag (a test was not carried out because causality was not demonstrated).