Table 4.
Summary of clinical literatures on demineralized bone matrices for spinal fusion
Ref. | Description of study | |
---|---|---|
Cervical spine | ||
An et al. [4] | A prospective comparison of an allograft-demineralized bone matrix composite versus autograft in anterior cervical spinal fusion | |
Lumbar spine | ||
Thalgott et al. [85] | A case series study for anterior lumbar interbody fusion with DBM composites consisting of titanium mesh cages, coralline hydroxyapatite | |
Girardi et al. [37] | Retrospective review of allograft demineralized bone matrix as bone extenders for posterolateral lumbar spine fusion | |
Sassard et al. [76] | Retrospective review of Grafton demineralized bone matrix as bone extenders for posterolateral lumbar spine fusion | |
Cammisa et al. [21] | A multicenter prospective study that compared the effectiveness of a Grafton DBM gel composite with an iliac crest autograft in posterolateral spinal fusion | |
Vaccaro et al. [96] | A prospective comparison of bone grafting with Grafton DBM putty enriched with aspirated bone marrow, DBM putty combined with iliac crest autograft, or autograft | |
Scoliosis | ||
Price et al. [73] | A retrospective study of determining the efficacy of a DBM composite consisting of DBM and bone marrow for posterior spinal fusion in scoliosis cases |
Ref. | Evidence level | Conclusion |
---|---|---|
Cervical spine | ||
An et al. [4] | I | The allograft-demineralized bone matrix construct gives a higher rate of graft collapse and pseudarthrosis |
Lumbar spine | ||
Thalgott et al. [85] | IV | The DBM composite was effective for anterior interbody fusion of the lumbar spine when used as part of a rigidly instrumented circumferential fusion |
Girardi et al. [37] | II | The use of these bone graft extenders may decrease the required amount of autologous bone graft |
Sassard et al. [76] | III | The percentage of patients fused was similar in both groups |
Cammisa et al. [21] | II | Grafton DBM could only extend an autograft that was smaller than is normally required to achieve a solid spinal fusion |
Vaccaro et al. [96] | II | The DBM composite consisting of DBM putty and aspirated bone marrow offer a similar performance as the autograft in posterolateral spinal fusion |
Scoliosis | ||
Price et al. [73] | III | The fusion rates were comparable to those of iliac bone autografts and DBM composites |