Table 1.
Scale | Sub-Scale | Items |
---|---|---|
Evidence* | Research | The proposed practice changes or guideline implementation: |
Are(is) supported by RCTs or other scientific evidence from the VA. | ||
Are(is) supported by RCTs or other scientific evidence from other healthcare systems. | ||
Should be effective, based on current scientific knowledge. | ||
Are(is) experimental, but may improve patient outcomes. | ||
Likely won't make much difference in patient outcomes**. | ||
Clinical Experiences | The proposed practice changes or guideline implementation: | |
Are supported by clinical experience with VA patients. | ||
Are supported by clinical experience with patients in other healthcare systems. | ||
Conform to the opinions of clinical experts in this setting. | ||
Have not been attempted in this setting**. | ||
Patient Preferences | The proposed practice changes or guideline implementation: | |
Have been well-accepted by VA patients in a pilot study. | ||
Are consistent with clinical practices that have been accepted by VA patients. | ||
Take into consideration the needs and preferences of VA patients. | ||
Appear to have more advantages than disadvantages for VA patients. | ||
Context | Leadership Culture | Senior leadership/clinical management in your organization: |
Reward clinical innovation and creativity to improve patient care. | ||
Solicit opinions of clinical staff regarding decisions about patient care. | ||
Seek ways to improve patient education and increase patient participation in treatment. | ||
Staff Culture | Staff members in your organization: | |
Have a sense of personal responsibility for improving patient care and outcomes. | ||
Cooperate to maintain and improve effectiveness of patient care. | ||
Are willing to innovate and/or experiment to improve clinical procedures. | ||
Are receptive to change in clinical processes. | ||
Leadership | Senior leadership/clinical management in your organization: | |
Provide effective management for continuous improvement of patient care. | ||
Clearly define areas of responsibility and authority for clinical managers and staff. | ||
Promote team building to solve clinical care problems. | ||
Promote communication among clinical services and units. | ||
Measurement | Senior leadership/clinical management in your organization: | |
Provide staff with information on VA performance measures and guidelines. | ||
Establish clear goals for patient care processes and outcomes. | ||
Provide staff members with feedback/data on effects of clinical decisions. | ||
Hold staff members accountable for achieving results. | ||
Opinion Leaders | Opinion leaders in your organization: | |
Believe that the current practice patterns can be improved. | ||
Encourage and support changes in practice patterns to improve patient care. | ||
Are willing to try new clinical protocols. | ||
Work cooperatively with senior leadership/clinical management to make appropriate changes. | ||
Resources | In general in my organization, when there is agreement that change needs to happen: | |
We have the necessary support in terms of budget or financial resources. | ||
We have the necessary support in terms of training. | ||
We have the necessary support in terms of facilities. | ||
We have the necessary support in terms of staffing. | ||
Facilitation | Leaders' Practices | Senior leadership/clinical management will: |
Propose a project that is appropriate and feasible. | ||
Provide clear goals for improvement in patient care. | ||
Establish a project schedule and deliverables. | ||
Designate a clinical champion(s) for the project. | ||
Clinical Champion | The project clinical champion: | |
Accepts responsibility for the success of this project. | ||
Has the authority to carry out the implementation. | ||
Is considered a clinical opinion leader. | ||
Works well with the intervention team and providers. | ||
Leadership Implementation Roles | Senior leadership/clinical management/staff opinion leaders: | |
Agree on the goals for this intervention. | ||
Will be informed and involved in the intervention. | ||
Agree on adequate resources to accomplish the intervention. | ||
Set a high priority on the success of the intervention. | ||
Implementation Team Roles | The implementation team members: | |
Share responsibility for the success of this project. | ||
Have clearly defined roles and responsibilities. | ||
Have release time or can accomplish intervention tasks within their regular work load. | ||
Have staff support and other resources required for the project. | ||
Implementation Plan | The implementation plan for this intervention: | |
Identifies specific roles and responsibilities. | ||
Clearly describes tasks and timelines. | ||
Includes appropriate provider/patient education. | ||
Acknowledges staff input and opinions. | ||
Project Communication | Communication will be maintained through: | |
Regular project meetings with the project champion and team members. | ||
Involvement of quality management staff in project planning and implementation. | ||
Regular feedback to clinical management on progress of project activities and resource needs. | ||
Regular feedback to clinicians on effects of practice changes on patient care/outcomes. | ||
Project Progress Tracking | Progress of the project will be measured by: | |
Collecting feedback from patients regarding proposed/implemented changes. | ||
Collecting feedback from staff regarding proposed/implemented changes. | ||
Developing and distributing regular performance measures to clinical staff. | ||
Providing a forum for presentation/discussion of results and implications for continued improvements. | ||
Project Resources | The following are available to make the selected plan work: | |
Staff incentives. | ||
Equipment and materials. | ||
Patient awareness/need. | ||
Provider buy-in. | ||
Intervention team. | ||
Evaluation protocol. | ||
Project Evaluation | Plans for evaluation and improvement of this intervention include: | |
Periodic outcome measurement. | ||
Staff participation/satisfaction survey. | ||
Patient satisfaction survey. | ||
Dissemination plan for performance measures. | ||
Review of results by clinical leadership. |
* The Evidence questions are preceded by a statement identifying the evidence-based practice that is the current target of intervention.
** Denotes items that are reverse coded.