Skip to main content
. 2010 Jun 28;107(28):12451–12456. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0908906107

Table 3.

Experts’ average ranking of physical processes influencing uncertainty in the global mean surface air temperature response to the three forcing scenarios displayed in Fig. 1

Rank Medium scenario High scenario Low scenario
1 Cloud radiative feedback Cloud radiative feedback Cloud radiative feedback
2 Sea-ice albedo feedback Land-ice and snow albedo feedback Sea-ice albedo feedback
Land-ice and snow albedo feedback Water vapor feedback Land-ice and snow albedo feedback
3 Water vapor feedback Vertical/diapycnal ocean mixing Deep water formation
Deep water formation Vegetation albedo feedback Ocean circulation (wind-driven and thermohaline)
Ocean circulation (wind-driven and thermohaline) Ocean circulation (wind-driven and thermohaline) Water vapor feedback
Vegetation albedo feedback Deep water formation Vegetation albedo feedback
Lapse rate feedback Sea-ice albedo feedback Lapse rate feedback
Vertical/diapycnal ocean mixing Lapse rate feedback Vertical/diapycnal ocean mixing
4 Atmospheric convection and precipitation Soil moisture Atmospheric convection and precipitation
Horizontal/isopycnal ocean mixing Large-scale atmospheric circulation Soil moisture
Soil moisture Horizontal/isopycnal ocean mixing Large-scale atmospheric circulation
Ocean eddies Atmospheric convection and precipitation Horizontal/isopycnal ocean mixing
Large-scale atmospheric circulation Ocean eddies Ocean eddies

Although the mean ranking of individual processes is sensitive to the ordering procedure used (details in SI Text), four sets of processes could be identified for each scenario whose ordering is independent on the specific procedure. Within each set, the processes are ranked according to the first ordering procedure described in SI Text.