Skip to main content
. 2009 Jun 4;2009:2301.
Ref (type) Population Outcome, Interventions Results and statistical analysis Effect size Favours
Sleepiness

Systematic review
178 people with OSAHS
4 RCTs in this analysis
Subjective sleepiness (Epworth Sleepiness Scale [ESS] score; see table 3 )
with automatically titrated CPAP
with CPAP

WMD for ESS –0.43
95% CI –1.55 to +0.68
See further information on studies for methodological weaknesses
Not significant

Systematic review
154 people with OSAHS
5 RCTs in this analysis
Subjective sleepiness (ESS score)
with automatically titrated CPAP
with CPAP
Absolute results not reported

WMD for ESS –0.36
95% CI –1.67 to +0.96
See further information on studies for methodological weaknesses
Not significant

Systematic review
154 people
5 RCTs in this analysis
Mean difference in sleepiness
with automatically titrated CPAP
with CPAP
Absolute results not reported

mean difference in sleepiness –0.56
95% CI –1.4 to +0.3
Not significant

RCT
Crossover design
46 people with severe OSAHS, mean baseline AHI 55 Sleepiness (mean change in ESS score)
7.9 with automatically titrated CPAP
8.4 with CPAP

Reported as not significant
P value not reported
Not significant

RCT
Crossover design
30 people with mean baseline AHI 41.1 Mean reduction in ESS score 1 month
6.1 with automatically titrated CPAP
6.1 with CPAP

Reported as not significant
P value not reported
Not significant

RCT
3-armed trial
78 people with moderate to severe OSAHS; median >4% oxygen saturation dip rate of 34.5 dips/hour, range 10.3 dips/hour to 89.0 dips/hour Reduction in ESS score 1 month
10 with automatically titrated CPAP plus CPAP
10.5 with CPAP
9 with automatically titrated CPAP alone
Absolute results not reported

P = 0.9 (for among-group difference)
Not significant
Intermediate outcomes

Systematic review
277 people
6 RCTs in this analysis
AHI (see table 2 )
with automatically titrated CPAP
with CPAP
Absolute results not reported

WMD –0.34
95% CI –1.20 to +0.52
See further information on studies for methodological weaknesses
Not significant

Systematic review
154 people
5 RCTs in this analysis
Mean difference in AHI
with automatically titrated CPAP
with CPAP
Absolute results not reported

mean difference in AHI –0.20
95% CI –0.74 to +0.35
Not significant

RCT
Crossover design
30 people with mean baseline AHI 41.1 Mean reduction in AHI 1 month
36.5 with automatically titrated CPAP
35.7 with CPAP
Absolute results not reported

P >0.05
Not significant

RCT
Crossover design
30 people with mean baseline AHI 41.1 Mean reduction in oxygen desaturation index (ODI)
24.8/hour with automatically titrated CPAP
25.0/hour with CPAP

Reported as not significant
P value not reported
Not significant

RCT
3-armed trial
78 people with moderate to severe OSAHS; median >4% oxygen saturation dip rate of 34.5 dips/hour, range 10.3 dips/hour to 89.0 dips/hour Median AHI 1 month
4.2 with automatically titrated CPAP plus CPAP
4.4 with CPAP
5.8 with automatically titrated CPAP alone

P = 0.4
Not significant