Table 5.
Stress paradigm | Studies | ANS | NE system | Immune system | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Measure | Response | Measure | Response | Measure | Response | ||
Psychological stress | HR | ↑ RA[29,37] | Cortisol | ↓/↑ RA[30] | Leucocytes | ↑ RA[36] | |
↑ Arthr[32] | 0 SLE[44] | ↑ SLE[44] | |||||
Cognitive tasks | [38]* [29,30,44] | SC | ↑ RA[29] | Lymphocytes | ↑ RA[30] | ||
[31]** [42]* | ↑ Arthr[32] | 0 SLE[44] | |||||
[32,36,37] | CO | ↑ RA[37] | T | 0 RA[30] | |||
PV | ↓ RA[36] | 0 SLE[44] | |||||
SVR | ↑ RA[37] | B | ↑ RA[30] | ||||
BP | ↑ RA[29,36,37] | 0 SLE[44] | |||||
CA | ↑ SLE[44] | NK | ↑ RA[30] | ||||
0 SLE[44] | |||||||
Th | 0 SLE[44] | ||||||
Tcyt | ↑ SLE[44] | ||||||
CRP | ↑ RA[36] | ||||||
Psychosocial | [40,41,45] | HR | ↑ RA[41] | Cortisol | ↑ RA[41] | Leucocytes | ↑ RA[40] |
tasks | ↑ SLE[45] | ACTH | ↑ RA[41] | ↑ SLE[40,45] | |||
BP | ↑ RA[41] | Lymphocytes | ↑ RA[40] | ||||
PEP | ↓ RA[41] | ↑ SLE [40,45] | |||||
CA | ↑ RA[40] | T | ↑ RA[40] | ||||
↑ SLE[40,45] | ↑ SLE[40,45] | ||||||
Tcyt | ↑ RA[40] | ||||||
↑ SLE[40,45] | |||||||
NK | ↑ RA[40] | ||||||
↑ SLE [40,45] | |||||||
Th | ↑ RA[40] | ||||||
0 SLE[40,45] | |||||||
NK toxicity | 0 RA[40] | ||||||
0 SLE[40,45] | |||||||
IL-6 | ↓ [41]/0 [40] RA | ||||||
0 SLE[40] | |||||||
IL-4 | 0 RA[40] | ||||||
↑ SLE[40] | |||||||
IL-2 | 0 RA[40] | ||||||
0 SLE[40] | |||||||
IL-10 | 0 RA[40] | ||||||
0 SLE[40] | |||||||
IFN-γ | 0 RA[40] | ||||||
0 SLE[40] | |||||||
TNF-α | ↑ RA[41] | ||||||
β - AR | 0 SLE[41] | ||||||
Exercise | [38]* [34,35] | Cortisol | ↓ RA[34,35] | Th | ↓ RA[35] | ||
↓ SLE[35] | ↓ SLE[35] | ||||||
ACTH | ↑ RA[34] | Tcyt | 0 RA[35] | ||||
GH | ↑ RA[34] | ↓ SLE[35] | |||||
IGF-I | 0 RA[34] | ||||||
PRL | 0 RA[35] | ||||||
0 SLE[35] | |||||||
Sensory stress | |||||||
Cold induction | [38]* [39] | NE | ↑ JIA[46] | Cortisol | ↑ RA[39] | Leucocytes | ↑ SLE[43] |
[31]** [46] | Lymphocytes | 0 SLE[43] | |||||
[33]** | T | 0 SLE[43] | |||||
Heat induction | [39] | Tcyt | ↑ SLE[43] | ||||
Acoustic stress | [43,42]* | B | ↑ SLE[43] | ||||
Pupillary light | [32]** | Th | ↓ SLE[43] | ||||
IL-6 | ↑ RA[39] | ||||||
↑ JIA[46] | |||||||
TNF-α | ↑ RA[39] |
↑ = increase in response to stressor, ↓ = decrease in response to stressor, 0 = no response to stressor. RA = rheumatoid arthritis, SLE = systemic lupus erythematosus, JIA = juvenile idiopathic arthritis, arthr = heterogeneous group of patients with inflammatory arthritis. * = study not described in Table because more than one stress paradigm was used, ** = study not described in Table due to lack of within-subject measurements. HR = heart rate, SC = skin conductance, BP = blood pressure, NE = norepinephrine, CA = catecholamines, PC = pupillary constriction, PV = plasma volume, PEP = pre-ejection period, CO = cardiac output, SVR = systemic vascular resistance, C = cortisol, ACTH = adrenocorticotropin hormone, PRL = prolactin, GH = growth hormone, β-AR = β adrenoceptor, IGF-I = insulin-like growth factor I, IFN-γ = interferon-γ, TNF-α = tumor necrosis factor α, IL = interleukin, CRP = C-reactive protein, B = B cell, T = T cell, Th = helper T cell, Tcyt = cytotoxic T cell, NK = natural killer cell.