Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2012 Feb 1.
Published in final edited form as: Sleep Med Rev. 2010 May 23;15(1):51–63. doi: 10.1016/j.smrv.2010.03.001

Table 1. Longitudinal Studies of Sleep, Depression, & Cardiovascular Disease.

Reference Sample and
Follow-Up
Sleep Measure(s) Depression
Measure
CVD Outcome Sleep Findings Depression
Findings
King
(29)
n = 495; 41% M
age: 35-47

FU: 5 yrs
- actigraphy over 6 nights
and self-reported habitual
sleep duration
- CES-D
- Cook-Medley
Hostility Scale
coronary artery
calcification
actigraphy: decreasing duration = ↑
calcification

self-reported duration: NS
Not Reported
Mallon
(30)
n = 1870; 48% M
age: 45-65

FU: 12 yrs
- DIS & DMS severity
- avg. duration
(< 6, 6-8*, > 8)
‘Do you feel
depressed?’
(Yes/No)
CVD mortality MEN: DIS = ↑ CVD mortality
  duration = NS
WOMEN: ALL NS
MEN: Depression =
↑ CVD mortality
WOMEN: Depression
= NS
Ayas
(31)
n = 71,617; 100% W
age: 45-65

FU: 10 yrs
avg. duration in 24-hr
(≤5, 6, 7, 8*, ≥9)
≤ 52 MHI
(assessed 6 yrs
after sleep)
nonfatal MI or
fatal CHD
≤ 5, ≥ 9 = ↑ CHD Not Reported
Chen
(32)
n = 93,175; 100%W
age: 50-79

FU: 7.5 yrs
avg. duration over past 4
weeks
(≤5, 6, 7*, 8, 9, ≥10)
5-item CES-D
scores (sleep
item excluded)
and history of
depression
fatal/nonfatal
ischemic stroke
adjusted for demographics +
depression: ≤ 6, 8, ≥ 9 = ↑ stroke

adjusted for CV risk factors:
≤ 6 = NS; 8, ≥ 9 = ↑ stroke

excluding baseline CVD:
≤ 6, 8, ≥ 9 = ↑ stroke
Not Reported
Ferrie
(33)
n = 9,781; 68% W
age: 35-55

FU1: 17 yrs
FU2: 12 yrs
avg. weeknight duration,
assessed at Phase 1 and
Phase 3 (~6 yrs later)

(≤ 5, 6, 7*, 8, ≥ 9)
GHQ scores
(sleep item
excluded)
CVD mortality Phase 1: all NS
Phase 3: ≤ 5 = ↑CVD mortality

decrease from 6, 7, or 8 hrs. b/w
Phase 1-Phase 3 = ↑ CVD mortality
Not Reported
Gangwisch
(34)
n = 4913, 36% M
age: 32-86

FU: 8-10 yrs
- avg. duration
(≤ 5, 6, 7-8*, ≥ 9)
-frequency of DIS & DMS
(combined in 1 scale)
≥ 16 on CES-D,
antidepressant
use
HT (self or
hospital report, or
cause of death)
Total Sample: ≤ 5 = ↑ HT
 - DIS/DMS = ↑ HT
 - with ≤ 5 & DIS/DMS in
 same model, both NS
ages 32-59: ≤ 5 = ↑ HT
 - DIS/DMS = ↑ HT
ages 60-86: all NS
Total Sample:
Depression = ↑ HT
ages 32-59:
-Depression = ↑ HT
-NS after adjusting
for ≤ 5 & DIS/DMS
ages 60-86:
Depression = NS
Ikehara
(35)
n = 98,634; 42% M
age: 40-79

FU: 14.3 yrs
avg. weekday duration
(< 4.5, 5, 6, 7*, 8, 9, ≥ 9.5)
4 study-specific
depressive
items
CVD mortality MEN:
8, 9, ≥ 9.5 = ↑ CVD mortality
WOMEN:
5, 8, 9, ≤ 9.5 = ↑ CVD mortality
Not Reported
Meisinger
(36)
n = 6896; 51% M
age: 45-74

FU: 10.1 yrs
avg. duration
(≤5, 6, 7, 8*, ≥9)
Zerssen affective
symptom
checklist
fatal/nonfatal MI,
sudden cardiac
death
MEN: All NS
WOMEN: ≤ 5 = ↑ MI
   DIS = ↑ MI
Not Reported
Cappuccio
(37)
n = 5766; 73% M
FU: 3 yrs
avg. weeknight duration
(≤ 5, 6, 7*, 8, ≥ 9)
SF-36 MHI &
GHQ scores
BP ≥ 140/90 or
HT medication
MEN: all NS
WOMEN: ≤ 5 = ↑ HT; NS after
adjusting for CVD risk factors &
depression
Not Reported
Patel
(38)
n = 82,969; 100% W
Mean age: 53

FU: 14 yrs
avg. duration in 24-hr
(≤ 5, 6, 7*, 8, ≥ 9)
≤ 52 MHI
(assessed 6 yrs
after sleep)
CVD mortality ≥ 9 = ↑ CVD mortality Not Reported
Stone
(39)
n = 8101; 100% W
age: 69+

FU: 7 yrs
avg. duration in 24-hr
(including naps)

(<6, 6-<8, 8-<9*, 9-<10, ≥10)
≥ 6 Geriatric
Depression
Scale
CVD mortality 9-<10, ≥ 10 = ↑ CVD mortality Not Reported
Lan
(40)
n = 3079; 57% M
age: 64+

FU: 10 yrs
avg. duration
(< 7, < 8*, < 9, < 10, ≥ 10)
≥ 5 on abridged
CES-D (possible
scores 0-24)
CVD mortality MEN: ≥ 10 = ↑ CVD mortality
WOMEN:
< 9, < 10, ≥ 10 = ↑ CVD mortality
Not Reported
Lopez-
Garcia
(41)
n = 890, 48% M
Mean age: 70

FU: 2 yrs
avg. duration
(4-5, 6, 7*, 8, 9, 10-15)
‘Depression with
need for
treatment’
(yes/no)
self-reported
hypertension
All NS Not Reported
Nicholson
(42)
n = 5449; 100% M
age: 32-86

FU: 6.8 yrs
sleep subscale from the
GHQ, classified as new,
former, or persistent
disturbances
Distress/anxiety
& depression
GHQ subscales,
classified as
new, former, or
persistent
CVD events:
CHD death,
nonfatal MI,
angina
-Persistent & former sleep
disturbances = ↑ CVD events

-New sleep disturbance = NS
persistent
distress/anxiety
subscale = ↑ CVD
depression
subscale = NS
Newman
(43)
n = 5888; 42% M
age: 65+

FU: 4.9 yrs
occurrence of DIS, DMS,
daytime sleepiness, &
snoring (‘yes/no’)
10-item CES-D 1.CVD death and
morbidity (MI,
angina, CHF,
stroke)
2. incident MI
3. CHF
MEN: all symptoms = NS

WOMEN: daytime sleepiness =
 ↑ CVD death/morbidity
 -all complaints = NS for MI
 -daytime sleepiness combined
 with DMS = ↑ CHF
CES-D = NS
Phillips
(44)
CVD sample
n = 11,863; 44% M
age: 35-55

FU: 6 yrs
occurrence of DIS, DMS, &
nonrestorative sleep
(‘yes/no’)
Maastricht
Questionnaire
fatal/ nonfatal MI
or other cardiac
event
All 3 sleep symptoms = ↑ CV events

Individual sleep complaints = NS
Not Reported
HT sample
n = 8757; 45% M
age: 45-65

FU: 6 yrs
occurrence of DIS, DMS, &
nonrestorative sleep
(‘yes/no’)
Maastricht
Questionnaire
SBP > 160,
DBP > 95, or
HT medication
DIS = ↑ HT
DMS = ↑ HT
Not Reported
Phillips
(45)
n = 1419; 41% M
age: 64-91

FU: 6 yrs
occurrence of DIS & DMS
(‘yes’/’no’)
≥ 10 on modified
CES-D
(0-30 range)
SBP ≥ 140, DBP
≥ 90, or history of
HT + medication
non-AA Men: DIS = ↓HT
AA WOMEN: DIS = ↑ HT (trend)
AA men, non-AA WOMEN: all NS
Not Reported
Schwartz
(46)
n = 2960 ; 34% M
age: 65+

FU: 3 yrs
frequency of DIS, DMS,
restless sleep, combined in
a continuous scale
modified CES-D fatal/nonfatal MI Adjusted for demographics &
education: DIS, restless sleep, &
sleep scale = ↑ MI

Adjusted for above + self-rated
health & depression: DIS, restless
sleep, & sleep scale = NS
CES-D = ↑ MI

X* = reference group. CES-D = Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale; CHD = coronary heart disease; CHF = coronary heart failure; CV = cardiovascular; CVD = cardiovascular disease; DBP = diastolic blood pressure; DIS = difficulty initiating sleep; DMS = difficulty maintaining sleep; GHQ = General Health Questionnaire; HT = hypertension; FU = follow-up; M = men; MI = myocardial infarction; NS = non-significant; MHI = Mental Health Index of the Short Form-36; SBP = systolic blood pressure; W = women.