Table 2. Studies of Sleep, Depression, & Diabetes or the Metabolic Syndrome.
Reference | Sample and Follow-Up |
Sleep Measure(s) | Depression Measure |
Metabolic Outcome |
Sleep Findings | Depression Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mallon (47) |
n = 1170; ?% M age: 45-65 FU: 12 yrs |
avg. duration (≤5, ≥9) DIS & DMS severity |
‘Do you feel depressed?’ (yes/no) |
self-reported diabetes |
MEN DMS = ↑ diabetes ≤ 5 = ↑ diabetes DIS, ≥9 = NS WOMEN: All NS |
Depression = ↑ diabetes after adjusting for age; risk was eliminated after full adjustment |
Ayas (48) |
n = 70,026; 100% W Mean age: 52.4 FU: 10 yrs |
avg. duration in 24 hours (≤5, 6, 7, 8*, ≥9) |
≤ 52 MHI | diabetes (asymptomatic & symptomatic) |
All Diabetes ≥ 9 = ↑ diabetes Symptomatic Diabetes ≤ 5, ≥ 9 = ↑ diabetes |
Not Reported |
Gangwisch (49) |
n = 8992; ?% M age: 32-86 FU: 8-10 yrs |
avg. duration (≤5, 6, 7*, 8, ≥9) |
≤ 16 CES-D | doctor/hospital diagnosed diabetes, or cause of death |
≤ 5, ≥ 9 = ↑ diabetes | CES-D = NS |
Gottlieb (50) |
n = 1486; 49% M age: 53-93 cross-sectional |
avg. weeknight duration (≤5, 6, 7-8*, ≥9) frequency of DIS, DMS, & sleeping pill use |
2 questions about depressed mood from MHI |
diabetes (oral glucose tolerance test) |
≤5, 6, ≥9 = ↑ diabetes DIS, DMS, sleeping pill use = NS |
Not Reported |
Hall (51) |
n = 1214; 57% M age: 30-54 cross-sectional |
avg. duration, weighted by weeknight & weekend (<6, <7, <8*, >8) |
CES-D, minus sleep item |
metabolic syndrome |
< 6, 6 - <7, > 8 = ↑ metabolic syndrome | CES-D = NS |
Eriksson (52) |
n = 5227; 41% M Mean age: 47 FU: 8-10 yrs. |
“frequency of insomnia over the past year” |
frequency of depression, anxiety, apathy over past year |
diabetes (oral glucose tolerance test or medication) |
MEN: insomnia= ↑ diabetes WOMEN: insomnia = NS |
MEN: anxiety, apathy = ↑ diabetes; depression = NS WOMEN: all NS |
Takeuchi (53) |
n = 1215; 100% M Mean age: 42.5 cross-sectional |
occurrence of DIS & DMS | depression and anxiety items on the POMS |
metabolic syndrome |
Not Reported | Depression = → Metabolic Syndrome Anxiety = NS |
Vgontzas (54) |
n = 1741; 48% M Mean age: 48.7 cross-sectional |
insomnia = complaint with a duration of at least 1 year; poor sleep = moderate to severe complaint of DIS, DMS, or unrefreshing sleep 1 night of sleep duration measured by PSG (< 5, 5-6, > 6*) |
treatment for depression |
diabetes (fasting blood glucose or diabetes treatment) |
Insomnia = ↑ diabetes, only in those sleeping < 5 hours in PSG study Poor sleep = NS |
Not Reported |
X* = reference group. AA = African American; SBP = systolic blood pressure; CES-D = Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale; CVD = cardiovascular disease; DBP = diastolic blood pressure; DIS = difficulty initiating sleep; DMS = difficulty maintaining sleep; GHQ = General Health Questionnaire; FU = follow-up; M = men; MHI = Mental Health Index of the Short Form-36; NS = non-significant; POMS = Profile of Mood States; PSG = polysomnography; W = women