Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.
Study | Year | Study size (n) |
Antidepressant used |
Diagnostic Criteria |
%age Bipolar |
Location | Ethnicity | Response criterion |
Remission Criterion |
Ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Smeraldi | 1998 | 53 | fluvoxamine | DSM IV | 27 | Italy | Not specified | HDRS 7 or less |
(11) | |
Kim | 2000 | 120 | fluoxetine or paroxetine |
DSM III R | 0 | USA | Korean ancestry | HDRS 50% reduction |
(22) | |
Pollock | 2000 | 95 | paroxetine or nortriptyline |
DSM IV | 0 | USA | Not specified | HDRS <11 | (23) | |
Zanardi | 2000 | 58 | paroxetine | DSM IV | unclear | Italy | Italian descent | HDRS 7 or less |
(24) | |
Zanardi | 2001 | 88 | fluvoxamine | DSM IV | 31 | Italy | Italian antecedents for at least two generations |
HDRS 7 or less |
(25) | |
Rausch | 2002 | 51 | fluoxetine | DSM IV | 0 | USA | Not specified | HDRS 50% reduction |
(26) | |
Yoshida | 2002 | 54 | fluvoxamine | DSM IV | 0 | Japan | Japanese | MADRS 50% reduction |
(27) | |
Yu | 2002 | 121 | fluoxetine | DSM IV | 0 | China | Ethnic Chinese | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(28) |
Arias | 2003 | 131 | citalopram | DSM IV | 0 | Spain | Spanish origin | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(29) |
Joyce | 2003 | 86 | fluoxetine | DSM III R | 9 (bipolar II) |
New Zealand |
95% European, largely British descent |
MADRS reduction 60% or more |
(30) | |
Durham | 2004 | 106 | sertraline | DSM IV | 0 | USA | 95.4% Caucasian, 2.8% Black, 1.38% other, and 0.46% Asian |
HDRS 50% reduction |
(31) | |
Lee | 2004 | 128 | various (57% SSRI) |
DSM IV | 0 | Korean | Korean | CGII 1 or 2 | (32) | |
Serretti | 2004 | 220 | paroxetine or fluvoxamine |
DSM IV | 42 | Italy | Italian antecedents for at least two generations |
HDRS 7 or less |
(33) | |
Kraft | 2005 | 96 | fluoxetine | DSM IV | 0 | USA | 78% Cauca- sian, 6% African American, 8% Hispanic, 5% Asian, and 3% other |
CGI I much or very much improved |
(34) | |
Kato | 2006 | 100 | paroxetine or fluvoxamine |
DSM IV | 0 | Japan | Japanese | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(35) |
Kim | 2006 | 241 | fluoxetine or sertraline |
DSM IV | unclear | Korea | Korean | HDRS 50% reduction |
(36) | |
Ng | 2006 | 45 | sertraline | DSM-IV | 0 | Australia & Malaysia |
67% Chinese 33% Caucasian |
HDRS 50% reduction |
(37) | |
Popp | 2006 | 109 | various | ICD 10 | 12 | Germany | 97% Caucasian | response on CGI |
(38) | |
STAR*D | 2006 | 1659 | citalopram | DSM IV | 0 | USA | 80% White, 14% Black, 6% Other |
QIDS-C16 50% reduction |
QIDS-C <6 | (39) |
Hong | 2006 | 224 | fluoxetine | DSM IV | 0 | Taiwan | Ethnic Chinese | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(40) |
Kirchheiner | 2007 | 190 | various | DSM IV | 12 | Germany | Caucasian | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(41) |
Bozina | 2007 | 130 | paroxetine | DSM-IV | 0 | Croatia | Caucasian (Croatian) | HDRS 50% reduction |
(42) | |
Kang | 2007 | 101 | mirtazapine | DSM-IV | unclear | Korea | Korean | HDRS 50% reduction |
(43) | |
Dogan | 2008 | 64 | sertraline | DSM-IV | 0 | Turkey | Turkish | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(44) |
Wilkie | 2009 | 166 | various | DSM-IV | 0 | UK | Caucasian | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(45) |
Ruhé | 2009 | 42 | paroxetine | DSM-IV | 0 | Netherlands | 69% Caucasian, 17% Creole, 14% Asian |
HDRS 50% reduction |
(46) | |
Maron | 2009 | 135 | escitalopram | DSM-IV | 0 | Estonia | 96% Estonian | HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(47) |
GENDEP | 2009 | 795 | escitalopram or nortriptyline |
DSM-IV / ICD-10 |
0 | Europe | White European parentage |
HDRS 50% reduction |
HDRS 7 or less |
(48) |