Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2011 Sep 15.
Published in final edited form as: Biol Psychiatry. 2010 Jul 7;68(6):536–543. doi: 10.1016/j.biopsych.2010.04.034

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

HDRS – Hamilton Depression Rating Scale. MADRS – Montgomery Asberg Depression Rating Scale. CGI – Clinical Global Impression Scale. Response and remission criteria refer to those used in this meta-analysis, in some cases alternative criteria were employed in original study publications.

Study Year Study
size (n)
Antidepressant
used
Diagnostic
Criteria
%age
Bipolar
Location Ethnicity Response
criterion
Remission
Criterion
Ref
Smeraldi 1998 53 fluvoxamine DSM IV 27 Italy Not specified HDRS 7 or
less
(11)
Kim 2000 120 fluoxetine or
paroxetine
DSM III R 0 USA Korean ancestry HDRS 50%
reduction
(22)
Pollock 2000 95 paroxetine or
nortriptyline
DSM IV 0 USA Not specified HDRS <11 (23)
Zanardi 2000 58 paroxetine DSM IV unclear Italy Italian descent HDRS 7 or
less
(24)
Zanardi 2001 88 fluvoxamine DSM IV 31 Italy Italian
antecedents for at
least two generations
HDRS 7 or
less
(25)
Rausch 2002 51 fluoxetine DSM IV 0 USA Not specified HDRS 50%
reduction
(26)
Yoshida 2002 54 fluvoxamine DSM IV 0 Japan Japanese MADRS 50%
reduction
(27)
Yu 2002 121 fluoxetine DSM IV 0 China Ethnic Chinese HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(28)
Arias 2003 131 citalopram DSM IV 0 Spain Spanish origin HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(29)
Joyce 2003 86 fluoxetine DSM III R 9 (bipolar
II)
New
Zealand
95% European,
largely British
descent
MADRS
reduction 60%
or more
(30)
Durham 2004 106 sertraline DSM IV 0 USA 95.4% Caucasian,
2.8% Black, 1.38%
other, and 0.46%
Asian
HDRS 50%
reduction
(31)
Lee 2004 128 various (57%
SSRI)
DSM IV 0 Korean Korean CGII 1 or 2 (32)
Serretti 2004 220 paroxetine or
fluvoxamine
DSM IV 42 Italy Italian
antecedents for at
least two generations
HDRS 7 or
less
(33)
Kraft 2005 96 fluoxetine DSM IV 0 USA 78% Cauca-
sian, 6% African
American, 8%
Hispanic, 5% Asian,
and 3% other
CGI I much or
very much
improved
(34)
Kato 2006 100 paroxetine or
fluvoxamine
DSM IV 0 Japan Japanese HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(35)
Kim 2006 241 fluoxetine or
sertraline
DSM IV unclear Korea Korean HDRS 50%
reduction
(36)
Ng 2006 45 sertraline DSM-IV 0 Australia &
Malaysia
67% Chinese 33%
Caucasian
HDRS 50%
reduction
(37)
Popp 2006 109 various ICD 10 12 Germany 97% Caucasian response on
CGI
(38)
STAR*D 2006 1659 citalopram DSM IV 0 USA 80% White, 14%
Black, 6% Other
QIDS-C16 50%
reduction
QIDS-C <6 (39)
Hong 2006 224 fluoxetine DSM IV 0 Taiwan Ethnic Chinese HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(40)
Kirchheiner 2007 190 various DSM IV 12 Germany Caucasian HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(41)
Bozina 2007 130 paroxetine DSM-IV 0 Croatia Caucasian (Croatian) HDRS 50%
reduction
(42)
Kang 2007 101 mirtazapine DSM-IV unclear Korea Korean HDRS 50%
reduction
(43)
Dogan 2008 64 sertraline DSM-IV 0 Turkey Turkish HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(44)
Wilkie 2009 166 various DSM-IV 0 UK Caucasian HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(45)
Ruhé 2009 42 paroxetine DSM-IV 0 Netherlands 69% Caucasian, 17%
Creole, 14% Asian
HDRS 50%
reduction
(46)
Maron 2009 135 escitalopram DSM-IV 0 Estonia 96% Estonian HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(47)
GENDEP 2009 795 escitalopram or
nortriptyline
DSM-IV /
ICD-10
0 Europe White European
parentage
HDRS 50%
reduction
HDRS 7 or
less
(48)