Fox, 1944 |
9 |
19%–80% |
Isotonic sodium lactate |
Less vomiting with sodium lactate than other sodium salts. Hypochloremic on day 2. |
Moyer. 1949 |
30 |
Not listed |
Hypotonic citrated or bicarbonated NaCl |
Hypotonic solutions reported to have low incidence of nausea and vomiting. Used IV LR & oral buffered saline. |
Markley, 1956 |
111 |
>10% |
Isotonic bicarbonated NaCl |
Vomiting less in oral group, 55% of cases used oral fluids only, rest received some IV LR or plasma |
Wilson, 1960 |
142 |
15–65% |
0.9% NaCl |
Patients denied oral resuscitation if peripheral vascular collapse, vomiting, or gastric dilation. |
Davies, 1964 |
20 |
10–40% |
Mayer's solution bicarbonated NaCl |
Always started with oral resuscitation, but about half required IV LR due to vomiting or deteriorating shock. |
Franke, 1964 |
22 |
8–70% |
Glucose-HCO3 electrolytes |
Used gastric infusion and anti- emetics. 19 (86%) received only enteral fluids. |
Sørensen, 1965 |
26 |
10–45% |
Clear fluids + salt tablets |
Administered water (100 to 200 mL/kg first 24-hrs) & 7.5-g salt tablet per L. |
Jackson, 1966 |
162 |
10–35% |
Mayer's solution Bicarbonated NaCl |
75% treated with oral fluids only, 25% also received IV plasma or LR. Vomiting occurred in 36% of patients. |
Monafo, 1970 |
7 |
22–95% |
Hypertonic lactated saline - 600 mOsm |
Combined oral & IV treatment with hypertonic lactated saline (HLS) |
Ahnefeld, 1975 |
68 |
12–34% |
Slightly hypertonic glucose electrolyte solution |
Toleration of gastric infusion of 1L was 97% of patients in first hr postburn, but only 30% at 1.5–3 hrs postburn. |
Maksimov, 1989 |
92 |
10–50% |
Isotonic bicarbonated NaCl |
Used enteral resuscitation exclusively in 12 patients w/moderate burns & to supplement IV therapy in 80 patients |
El-Sonbaty, 1991 |
20 |
10–20% |
WHO ORS |
Control group w/ LR - Parkland formula had equivalent outcomes |
Total |
709 |
|
|
|