Skip to main content
. 2010 Jun 8;59(9):1295–1312. doi: 10.1007/s00262-010-0869-2

Table 1.

Vaccination strategies: advantages versus disadvantages

Vaccination strategy Advantages Disadvantages
Whole tumor cells Complete Ag pool of an individual tumor (including Ags that have not been identified yet) Must be made individually for each patient
Activation of a polyclonal and more effective immune response Lack of co-stimulatory molecules on solid tumor cells
The immune system rather than the vaccinologist selects the most immunogenic tumor-specific Ags Immune response difficult to monitor
Induction of auto-immunity in the presence of adjuvant
Dendritic cells (DCs) Presentation of the vaccine Ags to other cell types of the immune system Must be made individually for each patient
Expression of high levels of HLA complexes and co-stimulatory molecules Generation of DCs technically challenging
Stimulation of both naive and memory T cells Money- and time-consuming treatment
DNA Easy and cheap to produce and purify DNA integration into the cell genome potentially promoting malignancy
Require no special handling or storage conditions Less effective than peptide vaccines in inducing CD8+ T cell response
Elicitation of both CD8+ and CD4+ immune responses as well as humoral responses
Peptides Easy to manufacture Immune response limited to one or few epitopes
Strong CD8+ T cell response HLA restriction
Known sequence and biochemistry Degradation in the absence of adjuvant
Allow specific monitoring of the patient’s immune response
Anti-idiotypic antibodies Unrestricted HLA population Human anti-mouse antibody response
Allow effective vaccination against non-protein Ags and poorly immunogenic Ags
Elicit both humoral and cellular immune response