TABLE 1.
Center | DNA extraction method (reference) | DNA target | Primer(s) (reference[s]) | PCR technologya | Amplicon detectionb | Inhibition controlc |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A | Tween-Noninet-NaOH method (19) | B1 gene | (6) | cnPCR | Gel electrophoresis + ethidium bromide staining | T. gondii DNA internal control |
rep529 | H1-H2 (unpublished) | cnPCR | Gel electrophoresis + ethidium bromide staining | T. gondii DNA internal control | ||
B | Qiagen QIAamp DNA mini kit | B1 gene | (29) | cnPCR | ELISA | Plasmidic internal control |
rep529 | (33, 38) | rtPCR | TaqMan MGB and LNAe | Plasmidic internal control | ||
C | Roche HighPure PCR template kit | B1 gene | (13) | rtPCR | FRET | β-Globin gene |
rep529 | (8) | rtPCR | FRET | β-Globin gene | ||
D | Qiagen QIAamp DNA mini kit | B1 gene | Primers 1-4 (7) | qrtPCR | Sybr Green | Plasmidic internal control |
rep529 | (20) | rtPCR | Sybr Green | Plasmidic internal controld | ||
E | Qiagen QIAamp DNA mini kit | B1 gene | (26) | rtPCR | FRET | Plasmidic competitive internal control (5) |
F | Qiagen QIAamp DNA blood mini kit | B1 gene | (15) | rtPCR | TaqMan | T. gondii DNA internal control |
rep529 | (15) | rtPCR | TaqMan | T. gondii DNA internal control | ||
G | Qiagen QIAamp DNA mini kit | B1 gene | (13) | rtPCR | FRET | β-Globin gene |
rep529 | (27) | rtPCR | FRET | β-Globin gene | ||
H | Qiagen QIAamp DNA blood mini kit | rep529 | (27) | cnPCR | Gel electrophoresis + ethidium bromide staining | T. gondii DNA internal control |
rep529 | (16) | rtPCR | FRET | T. gondii DNA internal control |
cnPCR, conventional PCR; rtPCR: real-time PCR.
Gel electrophoresis + ethidium bromide staining, direct visualization of DNA by ethidium bromide staining after agarose gel electrophoresis; ELISA, PCR-ELISA based upon the PCR-ELISA DIG labeling and PCR-ELISA DIG detection kits (Roche Diagnostics); TaqMan MGB and LNA, hydrolysis DNA probes (TaqMan technology; Applied Biosystems, Courtaboeuf, France); FRET, FRET hybridization DNA probes; Sybr green, Sybr green-based real-time PCR.
The absence of reaction inhibition was verified by amplifying a positive internal control concurrently and in the same reaction tube as the test DNA after the addition of a control sequence of target DNA; this control DNA may be either highly diluted T. gondii genomic DNA (equivalent to 1 or 0.5 tachyzoite genome), an artificial plasmidic DNA construct containing the primer sequences (amplified by the test primers), or a defined sequence of DNA amplified by a second primer pair, e.g., β-globin or albumin amplified under stringent conditions (to increase the PCR sensitivity to the presence of inhibitors in the sample).
Laboratory D also systematically performed one PCR with the matrix DNA diluted.
The two types of probes gave similar results.