Table 3.
Marker | Tools for measurement | Criteria | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Specific* | Validated‡ | Precise§ | Reliable | Noninvasive | Simple to perform | Inexpensive | ||
Diagnosing incipient Alzheimer disease | ||||||||
Medial temporal atrophy on visual rating | Visual rating scales | No | Yes | Moderately sensitive to early disease but poorly specific | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Hippocampal atrophy on volumetry | Manual tracing, automated tools | No | Yes | Moderately sensitive to early disease but poorly specific | Yes | Yes | Y/N | No |
Entorhinal and parahippocampal atrophy on volumetry | Manual tracing, thickness measurement | No | No | Moderately sensitive to early disease but poorly specific | Y/N | Yes | No | No |
Three-dimensional atrophy patterns | Support vector machines, STAND score | Yes | Yes | Yes | Y/N | Yes | Yes | Y/N |
Tracking progression in clinical trials | ||||||||
Hippocampal atrophy rate | Manual tracing, automated tools | No | NA | NA | Yes | Yes | Y/N | NA |
Cortical thinning pattern | Freesurfer, cortical pattern matching, CIVET algorithm | Yes | NA | NA | Yes | Yes | Y/N | NA |
Ventricular dilation rate | Threshold-based semi-automated measure, boundary shift integral | No | NA | NA | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Whole-brain atrophy rate | Boundary shift integral, SIENAX software | No | NA | NA | Yes | Yes | No | NA |
Diagnosis is considered as a one-time assessment. Criteria for validity were originally developed for diagnosis142 and adapted here to track disease progression.
Able to detect a fundamental feature of Alzheimer disease neuropathology.
Validated in neuropathologically confirmed Alzheimer disease cases.
Able to detect Alzheimer disease early in its course and distinguish it from other dementias.
Abbreviations: NA, not applicable; STAND, structural abnormality index; Y/N, moderately or uncertain.