Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 Sep 20.
Published in final edited form as: Ann Behav Med. 2009 Aug 27;37(3):239–256. doi: 10.1007/s12160-009-9111-x

Characteristics of the studies

Study N Sample type Optimism measure Health measure Study design Effect size (r)
Studies with objective health measure
 Allison et al. (2003) [41] 101 Head and neck cancer FLOT Survival at 1 year PR .06
 Brennan and Charnetski (2000) [42] 112 Undergraduates ASQ Immunoglobulin A CS −.02
 Brody et al. (2008) [43] 200 Diabetes mellitus LOT (pessimism) Glycosylated hemoglobin CS .10
 Cohen et al. (1999) [44] 39 Healthy women LOT Immune measure (mean of CD 4 counts of 3 months) LO .29
 Cohen et al. (1999) [44] 39 Healthy women LOT Immune measure (mean of CD 8 counts of 3 months) LO .02
 Cohen et al. (1999) [44] 39 Healthy women LOT Immune measure (mean of NK Cells counts of 3 months) LO −.03
 Contrada et al. (2004) [45] 142 Surgery LOT-R Post-surgical complications LO .10
 Costello et al. (2002) [2] 20 Temporomandibular disorder LOT Immune measure (IL-6) PR −.62
 De Moor et al. (2006) [46] 90 Cancer LOT-R Cancer antigen (CA 125) LO −.32
 de Ridder et al. (2004) [5] 65 Type I diabetes LOT-R Blood glucose CS −.15
 Friedman et al. (1993) [47] 1,178 Aging TC Death LO −.09
 Giltay et al. (2004) [48] 940 Aging SWB Survival PR .18
 Goetzmnn et al. (2007) [49] 76 Transplant patients (lung, liver, or bone marrow) LOT Survival PR .005
 Helgeson and Fritz (1999) [50] 298 Percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty LOT New coronary events (death from coronary artery disease, myocardial infarction, progression, etc.) PR .03
 Kennedy and Hughes (2004) [51] 50 Healthy undergraduates LOT-R Systolic blood pressure reactivity LO .30
 Kennedy and Hughes (2004) [51] 50 Healthy undergraduates LOT-R Diastolic blood pressure reactivity LO −.08
 Kennedy and Hughes (2004) [51] 50 Healthy undergraduates LOT-R Heart rate reactivity LO 0
 Kivimaki et al. (2005) [52] 5,007 Healthy people LOT-R Increase in number of sick days PR −.04
 Kohut et al. (2002) [53] 57 Aging LOT Immune measure (IL-10) LO .24
 Lee et al. (1995) [54] 89 Male Air Force cadets LOT Immune measure (PHA) LO .04
 Lee et al. (1995) [54] 89 Male Air Force cadets LOT Immune measure (PMA) LO .11
 Lee et al. (1995) [54] 89 Male Air Force cadets LOT Immune measure (anti-CD3) LO −.02
 Lobel et al. (2000) [55] 129 Pregnancy LOT Birth weight LO .20
 Lobel et al. (2000) [55] 129 Pregnancy LOT Gestational age LO .13
 Maruta et al. (2000) [56] 723 Aging MMPI (pessimism) Death PR .09
 Matthews et al. (2004) [57] 209 Healthy middle-aged women LOT (pessimism) Increase in carotid intima-media thickness PR .19
 Matthews et al. (2008) [58] 401 Healthy middle-aged women LOT Metabolic syndrome PR −.03
 Motivala et al. (1999) [8] 25 Type I and II diabetes LOT Disease duration CS −.41
 Nelson et al. (2003) [59] 982 Pregnancy LOT-R Pregnancy loss PR .09
 Raikkonen et al. (1999) [60] 100 Healthy people LOT Average systolic ambulatory blood pressure over 3 days PR .18
 Raikkonen et al. (1999) [60] 100 Healthy people LOT Average diastolic ambulatory blood pressure over 3 days PR .26
 Rini et al. (1999) [61] 230 Pregnancy LOT Birth weight LO .09
 Rini et al. (1999) [61] 230 Pregnancy LOT Gestational age LO .01
 Scheier et al. (1989) [36] 51 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Physical recovery PR .36
 Scheier et al. (1989) [36] 51 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Fewer post-operative complications PR .23
 Scheier et al. (1999) [13] 263 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Rehospitalization PR −.33
 Schofield et al. (2004) [14] 179 Lung cancer LOT Survival PR .03
 Schulz et al. (1996) [62] 238 Cancer LOT (pessimism) Mortality PR .14
 Schulz et al. (1996) [62] 238 Cancer LOT (optimism) Mortality PR .04
 Segerstrom (2001) [63] 22 Law students LOT-R Immune function (DTH skin test) PR .09
 Segerstrom et al. (2003) [64] 30 Medical and Law students LOT-R Immune function (DTH skin test) PR .12
 Segerstrom et al. (1998) [65] 50 Law students LOT Immune measure (CD4 helper T cells) PR .01
 Segerstrom et al. (1998) [65] 50 Law students LOT Immune measure (CD8-cytotoxic T cells) PR .25
 Segerstrom et al. (1998) [65] 50 Law students LOT Immune measure (CD19 B cells) PR .15
 Segerstrom et al. (1998) [65] 50 Law students LOT Immune measure (CD16+56 natural killer cells) PR −.01
 Tomakowsky et al. (2001) [66] 78 HIV/AIDS LOT Lower CD 4 counts CS −.05
 Tomakowsky et al. (2001) [66] 78 HIV/AIDS EASQ Lower CD 4 counts CS −.21
 Tomakowsky et al. (2001) [66] 47 HIV/AIDS LOT Decline in CD 4 counts at 2-year follow-up PR −.08
 Tomakowsky et al. (2001) [66] 47 HIV/AIDS EASQ Decline in CD 4 counts at 2-year follow-up PR −.43
 Von Ah and Kang (2007) [67] 49 Breast cancer LOT-R Disease stage at baseline CS −.06
 Von Ah and Kang (2007) [67] 49 Breast cancer LOT-R Lymph node status at baseline CS −.02
 Von Ah and Kang (2007) [67] 49 Breast cancer LOT-R Disease stage at post-treatment CS −.04
 Von Ah and Kang (2007) [67] 49 Breast cancer LOT-R Lymph node status at post-treatment CS .02
 Von Ah et al. (2007) [68] 54 Breast cancer LOT-R Immune measure (natural killer cells) CS .08
 Yi et al. (2008) [69] 111 Diabetes mellitus LOT Glycosylated hemoglobin LO −.11
Studies with subjective health measure
 Abend and Williamson (2002) [70] 63 Breast cancer LOT Patient report of cancer recurrence CS −.12
 Achat et al. (2000) [71] 659 Aging LOT Freedom from pain LO .06
 Affleck et al. (2001) [1] 89 Fibromyalgia LOT Mean daily pain LO −.04
 Affleck et al. (2001) [1] 89 Fibromyalgia LOT Mean daily fatigue LO −.13
 Allison et al. (2001) [72] 88 Head and neck cancer FLOT Freedom from pain CS .18
 Baker (2007) [73] 39 Undergraduates LOT (optimism) Physical symptoms LO −.18
 Baker (2007) [73] 39 Undergraduates LOT (pessimism) Physical symptoms LO .19
 Bennett and Elliot (2005) [74] 72 Post-cardiac event ASQ Physical symptoms LO −.54
 Bensten et al. (2008) [75] 101 Spinal fusion patients One-item measure (pessimism) Pain CS .57
 Brewer (2007) [76] 91 Knee surgery LOT-R Knee pain LO .07
 Chamberlain et al. (1992) [77] 50 Surgery LOT Knee pain PR −.14
 Chaney et al. (2004) [78] 42 Rheumatoid arthritis ASQ Pain LO .34
 Conway et al. (2008) [79] 67 Hypertension LOT-R (optimism) Physical symptoms CS −.25
 Conway et al. (2008) [79] 67 Hypertension LOT-R (pessimism) Physical symptoms CS .46
 Costello et al. (2002) [2] 20 Temporomandibular disorder LOT Pain PR −.02
 Curbow et al. (1993) [80] 135 Bone marrow transplants LOT Perceived health CS .25
 de Ridder et al. (2004) [5] 50 Multiple sclerosis LOT-R Physician rating of neurological disorder interfering with functioning CS −.11
 de Ridder et al. (2004) [5] 50 Multiple sclerosis LOT-R Physical functioning PR .06
 de Ridder et al. (2004) [5] 65 Type I diabetes LOT-R Physical functioning PR .24
 Ferreira and Sherman (2007) [81] 72 Osteoarthritis LOT-R Pain CS −.28
 Fitzgerald et al. (2000) [82] 50 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Reduction in post-CABG angina LO .29
 Fotiadou et al. (2008) [83] 100 Parents of cancer patients LOT-R Perceived health CS .26
 Fournier et al. (2002a) [6] 269 Chronic disease LOT-R Physical functioning at 6-month follow-up LO .24
 Fournier et al. (2002a) [6] 269 Chronic disease LOT-R Physical functioning at 1-year follow-up LO .24
 Fournier et al. (2002a) [6] 269 Chronic disease LOT-R Disease severity at 6-month follow-up LO −.22
 Fournier et al. (2002a) [6] 269 Chronic disease LOT-R Disease severity at 1-year follow-up LO −.21
 Fournier et al. (2002b) [7] 104 Type I diabetes LOT-R Patient report of physical functioning CS .15
 Fournier et al. (2002b) [7] 95 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT-R Patient report of physical functioning CS .25
 Fournier et al. (2002b) [7] 98 Multiple sclerosis LOT-R Patient report of physical functioning CS .33
 Fournier et al. (2002b) [7] 104 Type I diabetes LOT-R Physical symptoms CS −.26
 Fournier et al. (2002b) [7] 95 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT-R Physical symptoms CS −.36
 Fournier et al. (2002b) [7] 98 Multiple sclerosis LOT-R Physical symptoms CS −.29
 Fry (1995) [84] 37 Female executives LOT Physical symptoms CS −.44
 Glazer et al. (2002) [9] 46 Cardiac patients LOT Physical symptoms CS −.43
 Glazer et al. (2002) [9] 46 Cardiac patients LOT Physical symptoms at 3-month follow-up LO −.11
 Hamid (1990) [85] 75 Undergraduates LOT Influenza symptoms LO −.24
 Hooker et al. (1992) [86] 51 Alzheimer's caregivers LOT Perceived health CS .15
 Jackson et al. (2002) [87] 99 Undergraduates EASQ (pessimism) Physical illness PR .25
 King et al. (1998) [88] 75 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Angina LO 0
 Kurdek and Siesky (1990) [10] 48 HIV/AIDS LOT Physical symptoms CS −.06
 Lam et al. (2004) [89] 367 Breast cancer CLOT Physical symptoms CS −.25
 Lau and Knardahl (2008) [90] 1,946 Healthy adults One-item measure (optimism) Perceived health CS .27
 Lau and Knardahl (2008) [90] 1,946 Healthy adults One-item measure (optimism) Mean pain CS −.11
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1994) [11] 158 Undergraduates LOT Perceived health CS .28
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1994) [11] 158 Undergraduates LOT Upper respiratory illness (URI) symptoms CS −.23
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1994) [11] 158 Undergraduates LOT Physical symptoms CS −.17
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1994) [11] 138 Undergraduates LOT at 2-week follow-up Perceived health at 2-week follow-up CS .16
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1994) [11] 138 Undergraduates LOT at 2-week follow-up URI symptoms at 2-week follow-up CS −.01
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1994) [11] 138 Undergraduates LOT at 2-week follow-up Physical symptoms at 2-week follow-up CS −.08
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1998) [91] 175 Undergraduates LOT URI symptoms CS −.20
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1998) [91] 175 Undergraduates LOT Non-URI symptoms CS −.16
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1998) [91] 131 Undergraduates LOT URI symptoms LO −.32
 Lyons and Chamberlain (1998) [91] 131 Undergraduates LOT Non-URI symptoms LO −.21
 Mahler and Kulik (2000) [3] 215 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Pain at 2 week post coronary artery bypass surgery LO −.21
 Mahler and Kulik (2000) [3] 215 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Pain at 1 month post coronary artery bypass surgery LO −.17
 Mahler and Kulik (2000) [3] 215 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Pain at 3 months post coronary artery bypass surgery LO −.14
 Mahler and Kulik (2000) [3] 215 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Pain at 6 months post coronary artery bypass surgery LO −.17
 Mahler and Kulik (2000) [3] 215 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Pain at 12 months post coronary artery bypass surgery LO −.27
 Motivala et al. (1999) [8] 25 Type I and II diabetes LOT Physical symptoms CS −.47
 Northouse et al. (1999) [12] 98 Breast cancer LOT Physical symptoms CS −.48
 Pence (2007) [92] 27 Sickle cell patients LOT-R Mean pain LO .09
 Pritchard et al. (2007) [93] 242 Undergraduates LOT Physical symptoms PR −.16
 Pakenham and Rinaldis (2001) [94] 114 HIV/AIDS LOT Perceived health CS .07
 Ruthig et al. (2007) [95] 231 Aging LOT Perceived health CS .33
 Scheier et al. (1989) [36] 51 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Staff ratings of physical recovery PR .25
 Scheier et al. (1989) [36] 51 Coronary artery bypass surgery LOT Angina PR −.29
 Segerstrom (2007) [96] 61 Law students LOT Physical symptoms LO −.22
 Shen et al. (2004) [97] 149 Post-cardiac event LOT-R Physical health at 6-week follow-up LO .49
 Shepperd et al. (1996) [98] 22 Cardiac patients LOT Decrease in global coronary risk (self-report) LO .64
 Shnek et al. (2001) [99] 86 Cardiac patients LOT Chest pain CS −.29
 Smets et al. (1998) [100] 250 Cancer LOT Fatigue CS −.01
 Smets et al. (1998) [100] 250 Cancer LOT Fatigue at 2-week follow-up LO .03
 Smets et al. (1998) [100] 250 Cancer LOT Fatigue at 9-month follow-up LO .08
 Smith and Zautra (2004) [4] 64 Knee surgery LOT-R Pain CS .11
 Smith and Zautra (2004) [4] 64 Knee surgery LOT-R Pain PR −.02
 Tallman et al. (2007) [101] 56 Cancer LOT Physical functioning LO .42
 Tennen et al. (1992) [102] 54 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT Pain CS −.27
 Tennen et al. (1992) [102] 54 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT Disease activity CS −.09
 Treharne et al. (2007) [103] 117 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT (optimism) Pain LO .01
 Treharne et al. (2007) [103] 117 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT (pessimism) Pain LO .23
 Treharne et al. (2007) [103] 117 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT (optimism) Fatigue LO −.05
 Treharne et al. (2007) [103] 117 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT (pessimism) Fatigue LO .14
 Tomakowsky et al. (2001) [66] 78 HIV/AIDS LOT HIV symptoms CS −.30
 Tomakowsky et al. (2001) [66] 78 HIV/AIDS EASQ HIV symptoms CS −.28
 Treharne et al. (2005) [104] 154 Rheumatoid arthritis LOT Pain/fatigue CS −.13
 Treharne et al. (2001) [105] 125 Undergraduates LOT URI symptoms LO −.04
 Umstattd et al. (2007) [106] 231 Older women LOT-R (optimism) Physical functioning CS −.13
 Umstattd et al. (2007) [106] 231 Older women LOT-R (pessimism) Physical functioning CS .20
 Wong and Fielding (2007) [107] 144 Lung cancer patients Single item optimism measure Pain LO −.03
 Wyatt et al. (1999) [108] 699 Cancer LOT Physical symptoms CS −.21

LOT Life Orientation Test (Scheier and Carver [18]), LOT-R Life Orientation Test-Revised (Scheier et al. [19]), FLOT French life orientation test (Allison et al. [109]), CLOT Chinese life orientation test (Lai et al. [110]); ASQ Attributional Style Questionnaire (Peterson et al. [21]), EASQ Expanded Attributional Style Questionnaire (Peterson and Vallanova [22]), TC Terman cheerfulness (Friedman et al. [47]), SWB Dutch subjective well-being for older persons (Tempelman [111]), CS cross-sectional, LO longitudinal; PR prospective