Table 4.
Types of interventions, treatment regime and outcome measures
| Trial |
Intervention |
Trigger points and Acupuncture points selected for treatment |
Outcome measure |
Number of treatment sessions per week |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Tillu and Gupta (1998) |
25 mm acupuncture needle (diameter unknown) inserted for 15 minutes and stimulated every 5 minutes for 5 sec. Needle was manipulated to produce de qi. No control group. |
(i) Acupuncture points KI.3; BL.60 and SP.6 (ii) Gastrocnemius MTrP and heel MTrP. Specific location of MTrP in the heel and calf not identified. |
(i) Visual analogue scale (ii) Verbal pain score Outcome measures recorded at 4 and 6 weeks post baseline. |
4 sessions of acupuncture/1 per week. If symptoms were not resolved after this period, 2 sessions (1 per week) of acupuncture and dry needling were implemented. |
|
Imamura et al. (1998) |
22-25 gauge needle repetitively inserted and withdrawn with injection of 1% lidocaine into the MTrP; plus *standard therapy. Control group received conventional conservative therapy but not outlined in the methods. |
Medial head of Gastrocnemius; Soleus; Tibialis posterior; Popliteus; Abductor hallucis; Peroneus Longus and Flexor digitorum brevis |
(i) Duration of treatment (ii) Visual analogue scale (iii) Pressure pain threshold Outcome measures recorded at discharge, 6 and 24 months |
The number of sessions and times per week varied between the groups |
|
Perez-Millan and Foster (2001) |
10-120 mm acupuncture needle (0.20-0.25 mm diameter); plus electrostimulator (2-4 Hz) for 20-30 minutes. No control group. |
(i) Acupuncture points KI.1, 3, 6; BL.60, 67; GB 44 (ii) MTrPs points in the heel and arch regions |
(i) Visual analogue scale (ii) **Foot function index questionnaire Outcome measures recorded at 6 weeks post baseline |
6 sessions/1 per week |
Key:
MTrP = myofascial trigger point.
*Standard therapy = implemented once per day for three days following the injection: included: (i) heat (20min) and faradic stimulation over affected area for 20 min, (ii) stretching for three days, 3 times per day for 15 seconds after hot pack application, (iii) participants advised to avoid walking and standing for two days post injection.
** Foot function index questionnaire used in this trial was not validated.