Table 2.

Comparison of results

Author	Year	Patients	Followup	Dislocations	Comments
Bickels et al. [4]	2002	92	75	NA	Poor functional results in 7.5% of patients
Gosheger et al. [17]	2001	16	31	0	Use of trevira tube for soft tissue reconstruction
Camnasio et al. [7]	2008	36	26	3	Good results (Enneking score) in 30% of patients
O’Connor et al. [37]	1996	11	63	6	Two patients had arthrodesis due to symptomatic instability at 22 and 48 months respectively
Mourikis et al. [35]	2007	26	108	NA	No patient had postoperative normal range of motion and all were limited in flexion, abduction, and external rotation
Wittig et al. [50]	2002	23	120	0	MSTS scores 80% to 90%
Kiss et al. [24]	2007	14	51	11*	One patient required revision surgery
Kitagawa et al. [25]	2007	10	21	2	Mention in text of use of a “mesh” attached to the glenoid for soft tissue reconstruction (no further description)
Marulanda et al. [current study]	2010	16	26	0

NA = not available; *1 Dislocation and 10 symptomatic subluxations.