Table 5. Comparison of the species most frequently sampled in this study, with those in other urban ant studies.
Reference | Region | Distance from Manhattan, NY (km) | Total Species | Most abundant species | Shared species (with this study) | Notes |
This study | Manhattan, NY, USA | 0 | 14 | T. caespitum , L. neoniger , S. molesta , N. flavipes | 13/13 | |
Danoff-Burg & Melnick (2004) | Manhattan, New York City, USA | 0 | 24 | N. flavipes , Prenolepis imparis, Ponera pennsylvanica, L. neoniger , L. alienus, Aphaenogaster rudis | 7/13 | Unpublished data |
Nuhn & Wright (1979) | Raleigh, NC, USA | 650 | 59 | Pheidole vinlandica, Forelius pruinosus, Monomorium minimum, T. caespitum , L. neoniger , Nylanderia sp. parvula complex, Aphaenogaster spp. | 10/13 | Habitat surveyed was the North Carolina State University Campus in Raleigh |
Lessard & Buddle (2005) | Quebec, Canada | 715 | 24 | Aphaenogaster sp., Camponotus pennsylvanicus, Formica glacialis, L. alienus, L. neoniger , T. caespitum | 6/13 | Only the urban aspect of this study |
Thompson & McLachlan (2007) | Manitoba, Canada | 2000 | 10 | C. pennsylvanicus, F. glacialis, Lasius pallitarsis | 1/13 | Only the urban aspect of this study |
Sanford et al (2009) | Lake Tahoe basin, USA | 3800 | 42 | Formica sybilla, Formica lassioides, Myrmica tahoensis, Camponotus modoc, Formica accreta, Camponotus vicinus, T. sessile | 0/13 | Only the most urbanized of the sites characterized by this study. |
Suarez et al (1998) | Coastal southernCalifornia | 4000 | 46 | L. humile, Dorymyrmex insanus, Prenolepis imparis, Solenopsis molesta, Leptothorax andrei | 2/13 | |
Clarke et al (2008) | San Francisco | 4600 | 15 | Linipithema humile, Temnothorax andrei, Monomorium ergatogyna, T. sessile | 2/13 |
The number of shared species is in some cases an estimate as in some studies certain ant types were only identified to the genus level. For studies that had such separation of results, only the urban aspect was considered. Shared species indicates the number of species found in this study that were also found in each of the other studies, where the maximum would be 13/13.