Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2011 Jul 1.
Published in final edited form as: Ann Rheum Dis. 2009 Nov 5;69(7):1269–1274. doi: 10.1136/ard.2009.117200

Table 1.

List of recommendations with level of evidence and grade of recommendation, agreement, cost/risk ratio

Recommendation Level of evidence and grade
of recommendation
Agreement Cost/risk
1. Patient assessment.
    In addition to the standard care of patients without lupus of the same age and sex, the assessment of
    patients with SLE must include the evaluation of:
      disease activity by a valid  ated index at each visit
      organ damage annually
      general quality of life by patient history and/or by a 0–10 VAS (patient global score) at each visit
      comorbidities
      drug toxicity



5, D



97.6



L/VL
2. Cardiovascular risk factors
    At baseline and during follow-up at least once a year:
      assess smoking, vascular events (cerebral/cardiovascular), physical activity, oral contraceptives,
      hormonal therapies and family history of cardiovasculardisease
      perform blood tests: blood cholesterol, glucose
      examine for blood pressure, body mass index (and/or waist circumference)
    NB: some patients may need more frequent follow-up (ie, patients on glucocorticoids)



1b, B



98.1



L/VL
3. Othercomorbidities
    Osteoporosis. All patients with SLE:
      should be assessed for adequate calcium and vitamin D intake, re  gular exercise and smoking
      habits
      should be screened and followed for osteoporosis according to existing guidelines (a) for
      postmenopausal women; (b) for patients on steroids, or on any other medication that may
      reduce BMD
    Cancer. Cancer screening is recommended according to the guidelines for the general population,
    including cervical smear tests



2b, C



93.8



M/VL

2b, C

92.3

M/L
4. Infection risk
    Screening. We recommend that patients should be screened for:
      HIV based on the patient’s risk factors
      HCV, HBV based on the patient’s risk factors, particularly before IS drugs including high dose
      glucocorticoids are given
      tuberculosis, according to local guidelines, especially before IS drugs including high dose
      glucocorticoids are given
      CMV testing should be considered during treatment in selected patients.
    Vaccination. Patients with SLE are at high risk of infections, and prevention should be
    recommended.
    The administration of inactivated vaccines (especially flu and pneumococcus), following the
    Centers for Disease Control (CDC) guidelines for patients who are immunosuppressed, should be
    strongly encouraged in patients with SLE on IS drugs, preferably administered when the SLE is
    inactive. For other vaccinations, an individual risk/benefit analysis is recommended.
    Monitoring. At follow-up visits, continuous assessment of the risk of infection by taking into
    consideration the presence of
      severe neutropenia (<500 cells/mm3)
      severe lymphopenia (<500 cells/mm3)
      low IgG (<500 mg/dl)


2b, C


98.8


M/VL





5, D





93.5





M/M



1b, B



88.8



M/VL
5. Frequency of assessments
    In patients with no activity, no damage, no comorbidity we recommend assessments every
    6–12 months. During these visits, preventive measures should be emphasised.
5, D 93.8 M/L
6. Laboratory assessment
    We recommend the monitoring of the following autoantibodies and complement:
      at baseline: ANA, anti-dsDNA, anti-Ro, anti-La, anti-RNP, anti-Sm, anti-phospholipid, C3, C4
      re-evaluation in previously negative patients of: ant  i-phospholipid antibodies: prior to
      pregnancy, surgery, transplant and use of oestrogen-containing treatments, or in the presence of a
      new neurological or vascular event; anti-Ro and anti-La antibodies before pregnancy; anti-
      dsDNA/C3C4 may support evidence of disease acti  vity/remission
    Other laboratory assessments. At 6–12 months intervals patients with inactive disease should
    have:
      complete blood count
      erythrocyte sedimentation rate
      C reactive protein
      serum albumin
      serum creatinine (or eGFR)
      urinalysis and urine protein/creatinineratio
    NB: if a patient is on a specific drug treatment, monitoring for that drug is required as well




2b, C




92.3




M/VL
5, D 89.5 M/VL
7. Mucocutaneous involvement
    Mucocutaneous lesions should be characterised, according to the existing classification systems,
    as to whether they may be:
      LE specific
      LE non-specific
      LE mimickers
      drug-related
    Lesions should be assessed for activity and damage, using validated indices (ie, CLASI)

5, D

94.6

M/L
8. Kidney
      Patients with a persistently abnormal urinalysis or raised serum creatinine should have urine
      protein/creatinine ratio (or 24 h proteinuria), urine microscopy and renal ultrasound, and be
      considered for referral for biopsy.
      Patients with established nephropathy should have protein/creatinine ratio (or 24 h proteinuria)
      and immunological tests (C3, C4, anti-dsDNA), urine microscopy and blood pressure at least
      every 3 months for the first 2–3 years.
      Patients with established chronic renal disease (eGFR <60 ml or stable proteinuria >0.5 mg/24
      h) should be followed according to the National Kidney Foundation guidelines for chronic kidney
      disease.

1b, B

94.2

H/M
9. Neuropsychiatric manifestations
    Patients with SLE should be monitored for the presence of neuropsychological symptoms
    (seizures, paresthesiae, numbness, weakness, headache, epilepsy, depression, etc) by focused
    history.
    Cognitive impairment may be assessed by evaluating attention, concentration, word finding and
    memory difficulties (ie, by asking the patient about problems with multitasking, with household
    tasks, or memory). If there is a suspicion of any cognitive impairment, then the patient should be
    assessed in further detail.

2b, D

87.7

M/VL
10. Eye assessment
    In patients treated with glucocorticoids or antimalarials, a baseline eye examination is
    recommended according to standard guidelines. An eye examination during follow-up is
    recommended:
      in selected patients taking glucocorticoids (high risk of glaucoma or cataracts)
      in patients on antimalarial drugs, and (a) low risk: no further testing is required until after 5 years
      of baseline, after the first 5 years of treatment eye assessment is recommended yearly; (b) high
      risk: eye assessment is recommended yearly.



2b, D



95.8



M/L

ANA, anti-nuclear antibodies; BMD, bone mineral density; CLASI, Cutaneous Lupus Disease Area and Severity index; CMV, cytomegalovirus; dsDNA, double-stranded DNA; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; H, high; HBV, hepatitis B virus; HCV, hepatitis C virus; HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; IS, immunosuppressive; L, low; LE, lupus erythematosus; M, moderate; SLE, systemic lupus erythematosus; VAS, visual analogue scale; VH, very high; VL, very low.