Table 2.
Specific barriers | Lit ref | Identified critical key factors of influence | Problem level | Problem domain |
---|---|---|---|---|
1. No awareness of researchers about the policy process | [12,21,27,36] and mentioned in inventory |
Creating insight in working processes | Process | Expectations (Preparation phase of research) |
2. Finding researchable questions | [7,12,27,29,30,33,37,38] and mentioned in inventory |
Negotiate research questions, make an inventory on the need of information | Process | Expectations (Preparation phase of research) |
3. Answers about a specific item | [12,30,39,40] and mentioned in inventory |
Discuss limitations of study design and timelines | Process | Expectations (Preparation phase of research) |
4. Limited results by choice of study design, mostly cross-sectional studies, no causes and solutions | [12,27,39,40] and mentioned in inventory |
Discuss limitations of study design and timelines | Process | Expectations (Preparation phase of research) |
5. Degree of uncertainty | [12,21,27,39] | Discuss limitations of study design and timelines | Process | Expectations (Preparation phase of research) |
6. Actuality | [12,21,27,39] and mentioned in inventory |
Discuss limitations of study design and timelines | Process | Expectations (Preparation phase of research) |
7. Timing | [7,12,21,25,27,30,33,38,39,41-43] and mentioned in inventory |
Which research information is given at what time | Process | Expectations (Preparation phase of research) |
8. Language | [12,18,22,27,33,38,39,44,45] and mentioned in inventory |
For which target group is the information intended; what jargon is used How convincing is the research message How is the package What is the relation with other policy domains |
Process | Transfer (Publication phase of research) |
9. Conflicting knowledge by other Researchers |
[39,40,42,46] | Collecting other research information | Process | Transfer (Publication phase of research) |
10. Media | [12,43,47] | Communicating with media | Process | Transfer (Publication phase of research) |
11. Perceived robustness of evidence | [15,22,25,41,45,46,48-50] | How do stakeholders perceive the quality of the research | Individual | Acceptance |
12. Perceived credibility of source: researchers or other stakeholders | [25,28,29,38,41,43,51,52] and mentioned in inventory |
Who is bringing the message | Individual | Acceptance |
13. "Fit" with personal knowledge, values or belief systems, preferences and traditions | [25,41,43,46,50,51] and mentioned in inventory |
Individual | Acceptance | |
14. Consider whether or not a problem is important enough to deal with, relevance | [21,25,32,41,43,46,50,51] | Individual level | Interpretation | |
15. Consider connection with own personal or institutional interests | [21,25,32,41,43,46,50,51] | Individual level | Interpretation | |
16. Consider whose responsibility it is to take action | [21,25,32,43,46,50,51] | Individual level | Interpretation | |
17. Consider which solutions are at hand | [21,25,32,43,46,50,51] | Individual level | Interpretation |