Skip to main content
. 2010 Oct 19;7(10):e1000352. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000352

Table 3. Quality appraisal of included studies: time-series analyses.

Time-Series Analysis Study (First Author Name) Prospective Design Control Group Confounders Controlled Selection Bias Minimized Appropriate Statistical Measures
Econometric Ching [78] No No Yes Yes Yes
Venkataraman [40] No No Yes Yes Yes
Windmeijer [41] No No Yes Yes Yes
Chintagunta [42] No No Yes Yes Yes
Narayanan [43] No No Yes Yes Yes
Donohue [44] No No Yes Yes Yes
Mizik [45] No No Yes Yes Yes
Manchanda [46] No No Yes Yes Yes
Manchanda and Chintagunta [47] No No Yes Yes Yes
Berndt [48] No No Yes Yes Yes
Rosenthal [79] No No Yes No Yes
Azoulay [49] No No Yes Yes Yes
Rizzo [50] No No Yes No Yes
Hurwitz [51] No No Yes Yes Yes
Mackowiak [52] No No No Yes Yes
Leffler [53] No No Yes Yes Yes
Telser [54] No No Yes Yes Yes
Other Spurling [55] Yes No No No Yes
Stafford [56] Yes No No Yes No
Charbit [34] No No No Yes No
Auvray [57] No No No No No
Cleary [26] Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Soumerai [58] No Yes No Yes No