Table 2.
Characteristics of the included studies on individualised marketing of “environmentally friendly” modes of transport (walking, cycling, and public transport)
| Study | Country | Setting | Intervention | Control | Study population | Study design | Period of follow-up | Sample size* |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Haq et al, 200432 | England | Community | Individualised marketing along similar lines to IndiMark (see below) | Other households in the study areas that received no intervention | Households | Controlled cohort study | 6 months‡ | 227 |
| TravelSmart Brisbane (Marinelli and Roth), 200233 | Australia | Community | Individualised marketing (IndiMark): provision of tailored information, advice, and incentives to encourage change in travel behaviour in interested households | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled cohort study | 6 months† | 589 |
| Viernheim Household Transport (TAPESTRY), 200334 | Germany | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 6 or 8 months† | 987 |
| TravelSmart Perth (Department for Planning and Infrastructure, Government of Western Australia), 200335-37 | Australia | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 6 months† | 1959 |
| TravelSmart Frome (Sustrans), 200238, 39 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 2-3 months† | 749 |
| TravelSmart Gloucester (Sustrans), 200440-42 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 3 and 8 months† | 889 |
| TravelSmart Nottingham (Sustrans), 200443 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study§ | 6 months† | 1337 |
| TravelSmart Sheffield (Sustrans), 200444 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study§ | 3 and 9 months† | 986 |
| TravelSmart Melville (Socialdata Australia), 200445 | Australia | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 6 months† | 589 |
| TravelSmart Bishopston (Sustrans), 200446 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study§ | 3 and 9 months† | 993 |
| TravelSmart Cramlington (Sustrans), 200447 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study§ | 3 and 9 months† | 796 |
| Travel Options Kingston (Socialdata), 200448 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 1 and 10 months† | 693 |
| TravelSmart Doncaster (Socialdata, Sustrans), 200749 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 3 months† | 1871 |
| TravelSmart East Inverness (Socialdata, Sustrans), 200850 | Scotland | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 6 months† | 1129 |
| TravelSmart Lancashire (Socialdata, Sustrans), 2006-751, 52 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | Variable | 811 |
| TravelSmart Gloucester (Barton, Tredworth, and White City; Sustrans), 200653 | England | Community | IndiMark (see above) | Comparison area that received no intervention | Households | Controlled repeat cross sectional study | 6 months† | 1403 |
*Total number of participants in intervention and control groups combined at follow-up.
†Period of follow-up after completion of intervention.
‡Period of follow-up after inception of intervention (period of follow-up after completion either not reported or not applicable).
§Study involved elements of both repeated cross sectional and cohort designs.