Skip to main content
. 2010 Jul 27;118(10):1476–1482. doi: 10.1289/ehp.1002186

Table 4.

Effect of heater type (unflued gas heater – flued gas heater) on lung function.a

FEV1 morning (L)
FEV1 evening (L)
PEF morning (L/min)
PEF evening (L/min)
Population Unflued Flued Diff 95% CI p-Value Unflued Flued Diff 95% CI p-Value Unflued Flued Diff 95% CI p-Value Unflued Flued Diff 95% CI p-Value
ITT analysisb 1.95 1.95 0.004 −0.009 to 0.017 0.55 1.96 1.96 0.000 −0.014 to 0.014 0.99 271 270 0.719 −1.239 to 2.677 0.47 279 278 0.994 −0.995 to 2.983 0.33

Per protocol: days with heater use ≥ 30%c 1.91 1.88 0.030 0.003 to 0.057 0.03 1.91 1.91 0.008 −0.021 to 0.037 0.59 269 268 0.832 −3.505 to 5.168 0.71 277 272 5.185 1.032 to 9.338 0.01

Asthma subgroup, ITT analysisd 1.84 1.84 0.001 −0.038 to 0.041 0.95 1.84 1.85 −0.017 −0.061 to 0.027 0.45 253 250 2.285 −4.954 to 9.524 0.54 260 253 7.130 0.578 to 13.682 0.03

Asthma subgroup, per-protocol analysise 1.84 1.79 0.056 −0.027 to 0.139 0.19 1.74 1.80 −0.059 −0.174 to 0.056 0.31 255 255 0.021 −11.637 to 11.679 1.00 260 251 8.910 −7.543 to 25.362 0.29

Diff, difference.

a

The means and differences and the 95% CIs for the differences are derived from mixed model regression. Fixed effects were the heater type allocation, study period (first, second, or third pair of weeks), and day of the week. Schools and subjects within schools were both treated as random intercepts, and a variance components correlation structure was assumed.

b

All observations were analyzed according to the heater type exposure to which they were assigned. There were 6,776 observations for FEV1 morning and PEF morning and 6,504 observations for FEV1 evening and PEF evening

c

The analysis was limited to schools and days for which heater use was estimated as ≥ 30%. There were 1,249 observations for FEV1 morning and PEF morning and 1,441 observations for FEV1 evening and PEF evening.

d

All observations in subjects with current asthma at baseline were analyzed according to the heater type exposure to which they were assigned. There were 982 observations for FEV1 morning and PEF morning and 987 observations for FEV1 evening and PEF evening.

e

The analysis was limited to schools and days for which heater use was estimated as ≥ 30% in subjects with asthma. There were 169 observations for FEV1 morning and PEF morning and 213 observations for FEV1 evening and PEF evening.