Table 1.
Authors, year (reference) | Country, study period, and study population | Laboratory tests and clinical evaluation | MBL criteria | Frequency of MBL N (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Dagklis et al., 2009 (12) | Italy 2005–2007 Healthy volunteers in a geographically isolated rural area Total n: 1725 Age: 18–102 years Male 758; female 967 |
Flow cytometry Acquisition: 5 × 105 events/sample Five color: CD20/CD5/CD19/k/λ PCR amplification of IGHV-D-J rearrangements and sequence analysis Clinical records |
Mean B-cell count <5 × 109/L CLL-like: CD5bright CD20dim expression on CD19+ B-cells with a normal or an unbalanceda k:λ ratio Non-CLL like: CD5− MBL or atypical CLL-MBL with an unbalanced k:λ ratioa within CD5− or CD5+ B-cells |
All MBL: 128/1725 (7.4%) Male/female: (9.9%)/(5.5%) CLL-like: 89/1725 (5.2%) Male/female: (6.7%)/(3.9%) Age: <50 (0.8%), 50–69 (6.8%), >69 (9.2%) Unbalanced k/λ ratio: 83/89 Monoclonal B-cells/total B-cells: (mean = 6.9%) Non-CLL-like: 39/1725 (2.3%) Age: <50 (1.3%), 50–69 (1.5%), >69 (5.1%) CD5− MBL: 20/1725 (1.2%) |
Nieto et al., 2009 (13) | Spain 12 month period (not otherwise specified) Healthy volunteers from the primary health care system region of Salamanca Total n: 608 Age: >40 years Male 284; female 324 |
Flow cytometry Acquisition: 5 × 106 leukocytes/sample Eight color: CD20/CD45/CD8 +λ/CD56+k/CD4/CD19/CD3/CD38; CD20/CD45/Bcl2/CD23/CD19/CD10/CD5/CD38; CD20/k/λ/CD19/CD10/CD5 PCR amplification of IGH gene rearrangements |
A clonal B-cell cluster of minimum 50 cellular events CLL-like: “Circulating monoclonal B-cells with a CLL-phenotype” Non-CLL like (not otherwise specified) Normal lymphocyte counts |
All MBL: 87/608 (14.3%) Age: 40–49 (5.1%), 50–59 (5.3%), 60–69 (17.5%), 70–79 (21.7%), 80–89 (27.3%), >89 (75.0%) CLL-like MBL: 73/608 (12.0%) Male/female (13.8%)/(11.0%) k Restricted: 48/73 λ Restricted: 11/73 Biclonal: 14/73 Monoclonal B-cells/total B-cells: (median = 0.38%) Non-CLL like: 14/608 (2.3%) |
Shim et al., 2007 (20) | United States 1991–1994: baseline Volunteers living near or far from waste sites Total n: 1,926 Age: 40–76 years Male 934; female 992 1997, 2003: Follow-ups B-cell lymphocytosis cases at baseline only Total n: 74 |
Flow cytometry: Acquisition: not reported Two color (baseline), three color (1997), four color (2003) Extended panel for differential diagnosis (2003) Medical records review in the 2003 follow-up |
MBL: CLL-like phenotype determined by “CD20, CD19, and CD5 staining patterns” or the presence of a monoclonal population determined by an unbalanceda k:λ ratio No known history of a lymphoproliferative disorder |
Overall MBL: 11/1,926 (0.6%) Baseline: 9 and 1997 follow-up: 2 Male/female (0.6%)/(0.5%) Residents near waste sites (0.8%); far from waste sites (0.2%) |
Rachel et al., 2007 (14) | United States 2000–2002 Blood donors in a blood center Total n: 5141 Age: 17 years or older |
Flow cytometry Acquisition: not reported Two-color screening (CD19/CD5) Extended panel for cases with ≥40% CD19+ or >15% CD19/5 coexpression: CD45, CD14, CD8, CD3, HLA-DR, CD2, CD19, CD10, CD20, CD23, CD7, k, λ PCR analysis for IGH gene clonality |
B-cell count <5 × 109/L MBL: monoclonal B-cells expressing either “classical CLL” or “non-CLL subtypes” with a k:λ ratio >3:1 or <1:3 |
6/5141 (0.12%) k Restricted: 1/5141 (0.02%) λ Restricted: 5/5141 (0.1%) |
unbalanced k:λ ratio: a k:λ ratio of >3:1 or <1:3