Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2011 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2010 Nov;34(11):1871–1878. doi: 10.1111/j.1530-0277.2010.01275.x

TABLE 1.

LIST OF ATTRIBUTES TO CHARACTERIZE EACH HEALTH STATES BASED ON THE CLAMES SYSTEM (MCINTOSH ET AL., 2007)

Attribute Level Description
Core Attributes

Pain or discomfort 1 Generally free of pain and discomfort
2 Mild pain or discomfort
3 Moderate pain or discomfort
4 Severe pain or discomfort
Physical functioning 1 Generally no limitations in physical functioning
2 Mild limitations in physical functioning
3 Moderate limitations in physical functioning
4 Severe limitations in physical functioning
Emotional state 1 Happy and interested in life
2 Somewhat happy
3 Somewhat unhappy
4 Very unhappy
5 So unhappy that life is not worthwhile
Fatigue 1 Generally no feelings of tiredness, no lack of energy
2 Sometimes feel tired and have little energy
3 Most of the time feel tired and have little energy
4 Always feel tired and have no energy
Memory and thinking 1 Able to remember most things, think clearly and solve day-to-day problems
2 Able to remember most things but have some difficulty when trying to think and solve day-to-day problems
3 Somewhat forgetful, but able to think clearly and solve day-to-day problems
4 Very forgetful, and have great difficulty when trying to think or solve day-to-day problems
Social relationships 1 No limitations in the capacity to sustain social relationships
2 Mild limitations in the capacity to sustain social relationships
3 Moderate limitations in the capacity to sustain social relationships
4 Severe limitations in the capacity to sustain social relationships
5 No capacity or unable to relate to other people socially

Supplementary attributes

Anxiety 1 Generally not anxious
2 Mild levels of anxiety experienced occasionally
3 Moderate levels of anxiety experienced regularly
4 Severe levels of anxiety experienced most of the time
Speech 1 Able to be understood completely when speaking with strangers or friends
2 Able to be understood partially when speaking with strangers but able to be understood completely when speaking with people who know you well
3 Able to be understood partially when speaking with strangers and people who know you well
4 Unable to be understood when speaking to other people
Hearing 1 Able to hear what is said in a group conversation, without a hearing aid, with at least 3 other people
2 Able to hear what is said in a conversation with 1 other person in a quiet room, with or without a hearing aid, but require a hearing aid to hear what is said in a group conversation with at least 3 other people
3 Able to hear what is said in a conversation with 1 other person in a quiet room, with or without a hearing aid, but unable to hear what is said in a group conversation with at least 3 other people
4 Unable to hear what others say, even with a hearing aid
Vision 1 Able to see well enough, with or without glasses or contact lenses, to read ordinary newsprint and recognize a friend on the other side of the street
2 Unable to see well enough, even with glasses or contact lenses, to recognize a friend on the other side of the street but can see well enough to read ordinary print
3 Unable to see well enough, even with glasses or contact lenses, to read ordinary newsprint or to recognize a friend on the other side of the street
Use of hands and fingers 1 No limitations in the use of hands and fingers
2 Limitations in the use of hands and fingers but do not require special tools or the help of another person
3 Limitations in the use of hands and fingers, independent with special tools and do not require the help of another person
4 Limitations in the use of hands and fingers, require the help of another person for some tasks
5 Limitations in the use of hands and fingers, require the help of another person for most tasks

Score 1 - no problem; Scores 4 or 5 - the highest levels of disability