Table 1.
Examples of phase-specific mechanisms (or conditions, in the case of Phase I) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Pharmacological therapy | Surgery (e.g. hip replacement) | Physiotherapy | ‘Talking’ psychological therapies (e.g. CBT for depression) | |
Phase I – Set-up Conditions that must obtain in order to deliver the intervention | Correct diagnosis (implicit), availability of an appropriate formulation, etc. | Correct diagnosis (implicit), delivery of anaesthesia, clean instruments, etc. | Correct diagnosis (implicit), a comfortable environment in which the physiotherapeutic exercises can be performed, comfortable loose clothing, etc. | Correct diagnosis (implicit), establishing an appropriate (quiet, calm) environment, etc. |
Phase II – Delivery The time after the ‘set-up’ and before the technology reaches the proximate site of action 1.1.1 | Pharmaceutical and pharmacokinetic mechanisms (ADME) | (When the proximate site of action is accessed): skin, subcutaneous tissues, fat, muscle, blood vessels, etc. | (Such as when a preliminary strength exercise or stretch is performed): musculoskeletal system, nervous system, etc. | (The phase in which questions are asked, and problems are revealed): ‘mechanisms’ of speech, hearing, and understanding |
Phase III – Action When the technology achieves proximate actions 1.1.2 | Pharmacodynamic mechanisms | (When the problem is repaired): musculoskeletal mechanisms | (Such as a strength or flexibility exercise that improves neuromuscular functions): musculoskeletal, etc. | (When changes in understanding/ insight/ behaviour are achieved): cognitive mechanisms, etc. |
Phase IV – Outcome The patient-relevant outcome that results from proximate actions and outcomes | Mechanisms involved in death (when the outcome is mortality); any other mechanisms involved in quality of life and other patient relevant outcomes; palliation, cure, prevention | Mechanisms involved in death (when the outcome is mortality); any other mechanisms involved in quality of life and other patient relevant outcomes, etc. | Mechanisms involved in death (when the outcome is mortality); any other mechanisms involved in quality of life and other patient relevant outcomes, etc. | Mechanisms involved in quality of life and other patient relevant outcomes |
ADME = absorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion mechanisms