Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2011 Oct 1.
Published in final edited form as: Cogn Dev. 2010 OCT–DEC;25(4):309–324. doi: 10.1016/j.cogdev.2010.08.008

Table 1.

Rating Scales for Affective and Behavioral Qualities of Maternal Support

Scale Name Scale Description (Adaptation to Memory Conversations Indicated in
Parentheses)
Supportive
Presence
Degree to which mother provides emotional support to child's efforts.
1 = Mother fails to be supportive to the child, either being aloof and unavailable or
being hostile when the child shows need of some support. (Mother fails to show her
interest in child's memories; she is passive and uninvolved in the conversation.)
6 = Mother skillfully provides support throughout the session. If the child is having
difficulties, she finds ways to structure the problem to reward some sort of success by
the child and encourage whatever solution the child can make. Mother not only is
emotionally supportive but continuously reinforces the child's success. (Mother is
emotionally supportive by confirming, repeating, encouraging, and praising the
child's conversational contributions. If the child has difficulties in recalling the event,
she reassures the child that she has confidence in child's abilities to remember.
Mother often finishes the conversation by providing some kind of closing, saying for
example “Did you have fun there?” or “Do you want to do this again?”)
Respect for
Autonomy
Degree to which the mother's actions acknowledge the validity of child' perspective
and individuality.
1= Mother completely denies the child's individuality in the techniques she uses. She
is very intrusive and forceful in controlling the child. (Mother denies the child's point
of view and insists on her own agenda in the conversation; she shows no interest in
the child's opinion; she often interrupts and negates the child's contributions.)
6 = Mother encourages the child to acknowledge her/his intentions, and to negotiate
the course of interactions in the sessions. (Mother acknowledges the validity of the
child's perspective by giving the child an opportunity to talk, by following the themes
introduced by the child, and by focusing on the child's memories. She shows an
interest in the child's opinion and her/his version of the event.
Structure and
Limit Setting
Degree to which mother establishes structure and expectations for the child and
consistently sets limits on noncompliance.
1= Mother fails to communicate her expectations and shows no effective leadership;
she seems powerless to affect the child's behavior.
6 = Mother responds consistently and authoritatively to compliance problems; she
may be intrusive or respectful of child's autonomy, but achieves this level of structure
and limit setting.
Quality of
Instruction
Degree to which mother structures the tasks with cues that are clear about the task
objectives. Her provision of help is timely, clear, and useful.
1= Mother's instructions are of poor quality: she either is totally uninvolved or gives
clues that are of no help to the child's efforts and appears to embody no effective plan
of teaching. (Mother either does not provide any helpful information about the event,
or most of her information does not require the child's responses, or she repeatedly
asks the child for the same information. She often changes the topic of the
conversation, especially if the child had difficulties of remembering. The conversation
does not have a clear organization and narrative structure.)
6 = Mother structures the task that the child understands the objectives and can
attempt to solve the problems directly. Mother's assistance is matched to the child's
abilities and needs. (Mother provides a clear narrative structure in the form of open-
ended wh-questions that helps organize recall of the event. She clearly introduces the
event and makes sure that the child knows the topic of the discussion. She provides
additional, more effective cues to help the child in a timely manner. The mother's
approach suggests that she has some sort of a plan for how elaborative questions will
help the child to recall the event. Yet, she is also sensitive in recognizing the child's
themes during the conversations and is flexible in responding to these themes.)