Table 1.
- | - | “Repetitive task” survey | “Pays de la Loire” survey | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Type of criteria | “Complete”* | “Restricted” * | - | |
Years | 1993–1994 1996–1997 |
1993–1994 1996–1997 |
2002–2003 | |
ULWMSD questionnaire | Place | The worker alone in the occupational health service | The worker alone in the occupational health service | The worker alone in the occupational health service |
Number of pages | 10 | 10 | 3 | |
Place in the questionnaire | At the end | At the end | At the beginning | |
Symptoms | Pain and discomfort | Pain and discomfort | Ache, pain, discomfort | |
Recall period | Six months | Six months | Twelve months | |
Region | Neck/shoulder to fingers | Neck/shoulder to fingers | Shoulder to fingers | |
Drawing | Yes | Yes | Yes | |
Criteria for positive case | At least one symptom in the last 6 months | At least one symptom in the last 6 months | At least one symptom in the last 12 months/or last week | |
Clinical examination | Criteria | Standardized criteria specific of the study | Standardized criteria specific of the study | SALTSA criteria |
Number of clinicians | 39 in 1993–1994 18 in 1996–1997 |
39 in 1993–1994 18 in 1996–1997 |
80 | |
Number of disorders | 33 in 1993–1994 35 in 1996–1997 |
6 6 |
6 | |
Uncommon disorders | Yes | No | No | |
Specific tests | Systematic specific tests | Systematic specific tests | Specific test if symptoms at the interview by the practitioner | |
Blinding of examiners (towards symptoms) | No | No | No | |
Criteria for positive case | Positive if: -proved diagnosis at the examination -proved diagnosis before to the examination -suspected diagnosis |
Positive if: -proved diagnosis at the examination -proved diagnosis before to the examination -suspected diagnosis |
Positive if one specific test was positive |
“complete”, analyses considering all the disorders in the clinical examination; “restricted”, analyses restricted to six disorders.