Table 1.
SV | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | # pts | PSA Failure | Months Med f/u (mean) | modifiers | Failure rate | 5 yr DFS | 7 yr DFS | 10 yr DFS | ||
Swanson16 | 35 | >0.3 | 121 | EPE- mar- | 60% | 47% | 33% | |||
9 | EPE+mar- | 75% | 33% | 17% | ||||||
19 | EPE+mar+ | 95% | 10% | 0% | ||||||
Han22 | 113 | >0.2 | 76 | 48% | 30% | 17% | ||||
Roehl24 | NS | ≥ 0.3 | (65) | 26% | ||||||
Trapasso27 | 93 | >0.4 | 34 | 40% | ||||||
Sofer 29 | 10 | >0.3 | 43 | Gl 2-6 | 40% | |||||
30 | Gl 7 | 47% | ||||||||
26 | Gl 8-10 | 58% | ||||||||
18 | Cap pen | 67% | ||||||||
41 | EPE | 49% | ||||||||
34 | Mar+ | 56% | ||||||||
Stephenson30 | 195 | ≥ 0.2 x2 | 38 | Mar+ | 21% | |||||
224 | Mar- | 48% | ||||||||
Karakiewicz31 | 352 | 0.1-0.4 | 25 | Mar- | 43% | 20% | ||||
300 | Mar+ | 19% | 12% | |||||||
Hull 32 | 81 | 0.4 | 47 | 37% | 37% | |||||
Salomon33 | 137 | >0.2 | (59) | 52% | 34% | 10% | ||||
D'Amico 34 | PSA* | |||||||||
0-4 | 20-50 | |||||||||
70 NS | >0.1 | 42* | Gl 8-10 | Mar- | 66% | 96% | ||||
Mar + | 89% | 99% | ||||||||
Gl 7 | mar- | 55% | 91% | |||||||
Mar+ | 79% | 99% | ||||||||
Gl 5-6 | mar- | 51% | 88% | |||||||
Mar+ | 76% | 99% | ||||||||
Gl 2-4 | mar- | 36% | 74% | |||||||
Mar+ | 59% | 93% | ||||||||
Quinn 35 | 79 | >0.4 | 39 (41) | 30% | ||||||
Tefilli 36 | 59 | >0.4 | 43 | Mar+ | 14% | |||||
34 | Mar- | 49% | ||||||||
70 | PSA<10 | 59% | ||||||||
23 | PSA>10 | 17% | ||||||||
8 | Gl <7 | 45% | ||||||||
85 | Gl>7 | 22% | ||||||||
Freedland 37 | 135 | ≥ 0.2 x2 | 32 | 36% | ||||||
80 | Mar + | 21% | ||||||||
55 | Mar - | 56% |
Definition of failure and disease free survival: based on biochemical (PSA) failure and includes biopsy proven local recurrence and radiologically detected distant metastasis
* 2 year endpoint for all groups. Mar+ is margin positive; Mar- is margin negative; EPE+ is extraprostatic extension present; EPE- is extraprostatic extension absent; foc is focal; Ext is extensive; Est is established; Gl is Gleason score