Table 3.
Study | Instrument | Sample size (n) | time point | Index mean (SD) | Study population |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ALL INJURY PATIENTS | |||||
Keyes, US [19] | QOL | 854 | 24 months | 0.70 | Adults |
Meerding, Netherlands [36] | EQ-5D | 2904 | 2.5 months | 0.86 | all injury, age 15+ |
2.5 months | 0.63 | hospitalized 15+ | |||
5 months | 0.74 | hospitalized 15+ | |||
9 months | 0.74 | hospitalized 15+ | |||
Polinder, Netherlands [3] | EQ-5D | 525 | 2.5 months | 0.92 | all injury, age 4-15 |
379 | 5 months | 0.96 | all injury, age 4-15 | ||
366 | 9 months | 0.98 | all injury, age 4-15 | ||
Polinder. Netherlands [37] | EQ-5D | 3231 | 2.5 months | 0.60 | all injury, age 15+ |
5 months | 0.70 | all injury, age 15+ | |||
9 months | 0.76 | all injury, age 15+ | |||
24 months | 0.73 | all injury, age 15+ | |||
Sutherland, UK [32] | SF-6D | 200 | 2 months | 0.61 | Admitted, age 16-70 |
6 months | 0.62 | Admitted, age 16-70 | |||
Watson, Australia [34] | SF-6D | 186 | pre-injury | 0.91 | Admitted, age 18-74 |
186 | 12 months | 0.73 | Admitted, age 18-74 | ||
SEVERE INJURY PATIENTS | |||||
Gabbe, Australia [10] | HAQ | 243 | discharge | 0.44 | ISS > 15, age 15-80 |
6 months | 0.54 | ISS > 15, age 15-80 | |||
Holbrook US [12-14] | QWB | 1048 | discharge | 0.40 | GCS > 11, age 18+ |
6 months | 0.63 | GCS > 11, age 18+ | |||
12 months | 0.67 | GCS > 11, age 18+ | |||
18 months | 0.68 | GCS > 11, age 18+ | |||
Holtslag, Netherlands [64] | EQ-5D | 335 | 15 months | 0.69 | ISS > 15, age 15+ |
Korosec, Slovenia [61] | EQ-5D | 98 | 24 months | 0.72 | ICU patients |
Soberg, Norway [11] | WHODAS II * | 105 | 6 weeks | 0.59 | ISS > 15, age 18-67 |
12 months | 0.72 | ISS > 15, age 18-67 | |||
24 months | 0.73 | ISS > 15, age 18-67 |
* WHODAS II disability weights were reversed to utility scores
QOL = Satisfaction with Quality of Life instrument; EQ-5 D = European Quality of Life instrument -5 dimensions; SF-6D = Medical Outcome Study Short Form-6 dimensions; HAQ = Health Assessment Questionnaire; QWB = Quality of Well Being Scale; WHODASII = World Health Organization Disability Assessment Schedule version II