Table 4.
Sex differences in neurological disease.
Disease | Sex Bias | Evidence for the role of hormones | Evidence for the role of genetics | Other factors affecting sex differences in disease |
---|---|---|---|---|
Alzheimer's Disease (AD) | Women demonstrate higher AD prevalence at older ages [143; 144]. | Gonadal hormones implicated in gender-related cognitive deficits of AD but the interaction is complex [145] | APOE allele type [146; 147] (i.e. Less and slower rate of amyloid plaque formation in men due to APOE ε2 [148]) | Greater degeneration in areas of orbitofrontal cortex, middle and posterior cingulate cortex, hypothalamus, and mammilary bodies in men, and anterior thalamic in women [149]. |
Parkinson's disease (PD) | Overrepresented in males [150; 151] Age at onset is later in women [152]. Pathological symptoms of PD differ among males and females [153; 154; 155] |
Most women manifest PD after menopause [156] Estrogen affecting BDNF secretion [157] Early life estrogen decline seems to be more important [158; 159; 160] |
Linkage to X chromosome markers in 362 families, and to Xq28 in 443 discordant sibling pairs [161; 162] Val66met polymorphism in BDNF in women [163] |
Environmental factors [164] Anatomical and structural differences in dopaminergic systems among males and females [107] |
Autism | There is a high male to female ratio in the prevalence of autism [165] | Gonadal hormones affecting oxytocin (OT) and arginine vasopressin (AVP) receptors [166; 167] | Single nucleotide polymorphisms in the OT receptor in the Chinese Han [168] and American Caucasian population [169], SNPs in the vasopressin receptor (V1aR) gene [170; 171] X-chromosome has effects on cognition and social aspects [172; 173] |
Alterations in oxytocin or arginine vasopressin activity, and differential processing of the oxytocin precursor [174; 175; 176] |
Addiction | Drug addiction more frequent in men [12] Higher relapse rates, faster progression of compulsive drug abuse and dependence have in women [177; 178]) |
Estradiol levels correlate with drug induced reinforcing behavior whereas progesterone levels are negatively associated with addiction [179; 180; 181] | Genes encoded on sex chromosomes can affect sex-related differences in addiction (the four core genotype mice) [182] | Neuroanatomical differences in motivation systems among males and females [107] Sex-related alterations in the cortico-limbic-striatal system that mediates reward processing [183] |
Depression | Women are twice as likely as men to develop depression during reproductive years [184] | Low estrogen levels in female rats mediated by influences on neurotransmitter levels [185] Low testosterone levels associate with risk for depression in young and middle aged-men [186; 187] |
Heritability rates estimated to be 70% [188] Polymorphisms in serotonin gene, estrogen receptor 1 (ESR1) polymorphism in the presence of Val/Val genotype of the Val158Met polymorphism in the Catechol-O-methyl transferase (COMT) gene, longer CA repeats of human estrogen receptor 2 (ESR2), short CAG repeats in androgen receptor gene [189] |
Maladaptive coping, pessimism, dependency, low self- esteem, victimization, sexual abuse, comorbid anxiety disorder more common in depressed women [190] Early life events increase depression rates in adult women [191] |
Anxiety disorders | The rate of anxiety disorders is higher in females [55]. The high comorbidity of these disorders with major depression helps account for the sex difference in depression [192]. | States of anxiety and panic have been reported to be affected by the menstrual cycle and pregnancy, implicating a role for estrogen and progesterone [55]. Pregnancy and lactation seem to alter brain neurochemical system that affect anxiety and fear [193]. |
TheVal158alleleof COMT is associated with panic disorder in Caucasian women but not men [194]. In Asians, Met158 is associated with panic disorder in women but not men [194]. 5HTTLPR is a polymorphism associated with anxiety in humans. The orthologous polymorphism in rhesus macaques interacts with early adversity in a sexually dimorphic manner [195]. |
Animal studies indicate females undergo less neurobiological changes in response to stress compared to males [193]. It is speculated that this indicates increased adaptability in males and hence lower prevalence of affective illness [193]. |
Schizophrenia | more common in men than in women [196] Age at onset is later in women, another smaller peak of onset during peri- and post-menopause [196; 197] Pathological symptoms of schizophrenia differ among males and females (males experience more negative symptoms, greater decrease in emotion expression and recognition,, greater paranoid delusions in women) [198] Lower chances of full recovery, and a poorer prognosis in men [196; 197] Anatomical brain differences between male and female patients |
This disease is not common before adolescence and puberty [199] Male schizophrenics have higher levels of Luteinizing Hormone (LH) and testosterone than healthy subjects, and female schizophrenics higher levels of LH and lower levels of estrogen [200] |
Eight ultra-rare variants in eight distinct miRNA genes in 4% of analyzed males with schizophrenia [201] Relatives of females with schizophrenia demonstrate higher levels of the psychotic forms whereas relatives of schizophrenic men express lower rates of psychosis suggesting the presence of genetic heterogeneity [202] Higher rate of CAG repeat expansions among families of female patients and not male patients [203] |
Anatomical and structural brain differences among males and females [198] Higher cortical levels in males as compared to females according to some studies [198] Higher sensitivity of the dopamine system in men as compared to women (Normal males produce more striatal dopamine in response to an amphetamine challenge as compared to females) [204] |