Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2012 Apr 15.
Published in final edited form as: J Comput Chem. 2010 Oct 14;32(5):866–877. doi: 10.1002/jcc.21666

Table 1.

Success rates of MM/PBSA and MM/GBSA considering one to five best scored conformations

Success rate (%)

Scoring functions Best 1 Best two Best three Best four Best five
MM/GBSA (igb=1, εin=1) 64.3(63/98) 78.6(77/98) 85.7(84/98) 85.8(84/98) 88.8(87/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=1, εin=2) 67.3(66/98) 76.5(75/98) 82.7(81/98) 84.7(83/98) 85.7(84/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=1, εin=4) 54.1(53/98) 69.4(68/98) 71.4(70/98) 76.5(75/98) 77.6(76/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=2, εin=1) 62.2(61/98) 77.6(76/98) 84.7(83/98) 86.7(85/98) 88.8(87/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=2, εin=2) 69.4(68/98) 76.5(75/98) 82.7(81/98) 83.7(82/98) 85.7(84/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=2, εin=4) 58.2(57/98) 71.4(70/98) 73.5(72/98) 75.5(74/98) 77.6(76/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=5, εin=1) 31.6(31/98) 49.0(48/98) 56.1(55/98) 60.2(59/98) 65.3(64/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=5, εin=2) 39.8(39/98) 55.1(54/98) 59.2(58/98) 66.3(65/98) 69.4(68/98)
MM/GBSA (igb=5, εin=4) 43.9(43/98) 55.1(54/98) 63.3(62/98) 68.4(67/98) 75.5(74/98)
MM/PBSA (εin=1) 38.8(38/98) 43.9(43/98) 50.0(49/98) 50.0(50/98) 53.1(52/98)
MM/PBSA (εin=2) 56.1(55/98) 56.1(55/98) 60.2(59/98) 66.3(65/98) 68.4(67/98)
MM/PBSA (εin=4) 50.0(49/98) 63.3(62/98) 69.7(69/99 75.5(74/98) 79.6(78/98)