Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2012 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 2010 Nov 13;33(1):29–36. doi: 10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2010.10.002

Table 1.

Characteristics of Randomized Trials of Peer Support Interventions for Depression

Study N % Female Mean Age Primary Study Inclusion criteria Depression Outcome Measure Peer Support Intervention Control Condition(s)
Ayen I. et al, 2004 51 100 46–56 (range) BDI > 13, no menstrual period in last 12 months BDI 12 session weekly PSG CBT, Usual care
Bright JI. et al, 1999 98 71 46 HSRD > 10 BDI, HRSD 10 session weekly PSG CBT
Chen CH.et al, 2000 60 100 29 BDI > 9/10, post-partum BDI 4–5 session weekly PSG Usual care
Dennis CL., 2009 701 100 20–34 (median) EPDS > 9, post-partum EPDS ~10 weeks telephone peer mentor Usual care
Evans RL. et al, 1995 78 32 54 CES-D > 15, stage II cancer with planned XRT CES-D 8 session weekly PSG CBT, Usual care
Kelly JA. et al, 1993 68 0 34 CES-D > 15, HIV positive CES-D 8 session weekly PSG CBT, Usual care
Maynard CK. et al, 1993 34 100 45 Depressed women (self-identified) BDI 12 session weekly PSG CBT, Usual care*
Michielin P. et al, 2007 40 Not reported 56–59 BDI > 9, caregiver for someone with serious mental illness BDI 10 session PSG over 15 weeks CBT
Ong Y. et al, 1987 20 85 74 Depressed elderly patients (Feighner research criteria) following inpatient stay Zung depression scale 9 months weekly PSG Usual care
Verduyn C. et al, 2003 119 100 30 BDI > 14, mother of pre-school aged child BDI, HRSD 16 session weekly PSG CBT, Usual care

PSG = Peer support group, CBT = group cognitive behavioral therapy, BDI = Beck Depression Inventory, CES-D = Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression scale

EPDS = Edinborough Postpartum Depression Scale, HRSD = Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression, HRSD = Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression

*

Patients were not randomized to this condition and therefore it was excluded from the meta-analyses