Table 2.
Study | N | Mean Age |
Age Range |
Gender (% Female) |
Mean Education (Years) |
Criteria for “Health” |
Factors Measured Longitudinally |
Study Interval: Mean (SD); Range |
Imaging Modality |
Image Analysis Method |
Brain Measure(s) |
Correction to Brain Measures |
Cognitive Domains Measured |
Age Effect on Brain Structure |
Relationship between Brain Structure and Cognition |
Comparison of Structure- Cognition Relationships in Older Adults vs. Younger Adults |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Samples
of Older Adults |
Cohen et al., 2001{47} |
25 | 57.1 | 50+ | 100% | 16.7 | Physical, Cognitive |
Brain and Cognition |
~2 years | MRI | Mixed | Volume of hippocampus [L+R] |
--- | Attention/ Working Memory, Executive Function, Verbal & Visual Memory, Visuospatial Processing |
↓ Hippo- campus |
Volume changes unassociated with cognitive changes. Baseline hippo- campal volume* unassociated with baseline cognition*. |
--- |
Cook et al., 2004{68} |
29 | 74.8 | 60-89 | 58.6% | 15.5 | Physical, Psychological. Substance Abuse |
Brain and Cognition |
3.6 years (0.8); 2-6 years |
MRI | Mixed | Volume of sulcal and ventricular CSF |
ICV | Abstract Reasoning, Executive Function, Language, Processing Speed |
↑ Sulcal & ventricular CSF |
Minimal change in cognition, thus unable to examine longitudinal effects. Cognition at follow-up* unrelated to CSF at follow-up*. |
--- | |
Du et al., 2003{48} |
23 | 76.5 | --- | 30.4% | --- | Physical, Cognitive, Psychological, Substance Abuse |
Brain | 1.8 years | MRI | Manual | Volume of entorhinal cortex [L&R] |
ICV | Verbal Memory |
↓ Entorhinal cortex [L&R] |
Volume change not associated with memory*. |
--- | |
Golomb et al., 1996{27} |
44 | 68.5 | 55+ | 59.1% | 15.1 | Physical, Cognitive, Psychological, Substance Abuse |
Cognition | 3.8 years (1.0); 2-6 years |
MRI | Manual | Volume of HF, superior temporal gyrus, CSF [L+R] |
ICV | Global, Verbal Memory |
--- | Smaller hippocampus (baseline)* = ↓ memory†. |
--- | |
Marquis et al., 2002{19} |
108 | 83.2 | 65+ | 63.0% | 14.1 | Physical, Cognitive, Substance Abuse |
Cognition | 6 years (2.6) |
MRI | Manual | Volume of hippocampus, total volume [L+R] |
--- | Global, Verbal Memory |
↓ Hippo- campus |
Smaller hippo- campus [L+R], total volume (baseline)* = ↓ global cognition†. No relationships with memory. |
--- | |
Tisserand et al., 2004{22} |
75 | 72.2 | 52-84 | 50.7% | “lower vocational education / intermediat e secondary education” |
Physical, Cognitive, Substance Abuse |
Cognition | ~3 years | MRI | Automated | Total GM, WM, and CSF volume. VBM of GM. ROIs: PFC and medial temporal lobe (all measured at “follow- up”) |
--- | Global, Attention/ Working Memory, Executive Function, Processing Speed, Verbal Memory (“non- decliners” vs. “decliners”) |
Overall: ↓ GM*, ↑ CSF*. Non- decliners: ↓ GM* (especially PFC [L&R], medial temporal lobe [L&R], striate cortex). |
Non-decliners > Decliners in GM* (especially in PFC, R temporal lobe, and R posterior parietal cortex). Non-decliners < Decliners in CSF*. |
--- | |
Visser et al., 1999{36} |
18 | 76.8 | 65-85 | 56% | 8.2 | Cognitive, Psychological |
Cognition | ~3 years | MRI | Mixed | Volume of hippocampus, parahippo- campal gyrus, medial temporal lobe [L+R] |
ICV | Global, Verbal & Visual Memory |
--- | No relationship between volumes* and cognition* at baseline. Larger parahippocampal gyrus* = ↑ memory, global cognition |
--- | |
Samples
of Younger and Older Adults |
McArdle et al., 2004{26} |
225 | --- | 30-80 | 51.6% | 14.4 | Physical, Psychological |
Brain and Cognition |
~ 7 years | CT | --- | Lateral ventricle size [L+R] |
Head size | Attention/ Working Memory, Verbal & Visual Memory |
↑ Lateral ventricle size |
↑ Lateral ventricle size = ↓ memory |
Relationship between lateral ventricle size and memory strengthens with age |
Raz et al., 2005{69} |
72 | 52.6 | 20-77 | 58.3% | 15.9 | Physical, Cognitive, Psychological |
Brain and Cognition |
5.3 years (0.3); 4.8- 6.1 years |
MRI | Manual | Volume of lateral PFC, orbital frontal cortex, prefrontal WM, inferior parietal lob- ule, inferior parietal WM, inferior temp- oral cortex, fusiform cortex, percalcarine cortex, hippocampus, entorhinal cortex, caudate, cerebellum [L+R] |
ICV | Global | Mean ↓ all ROIs except visual cortex. Individual ↓ for all ROIs except inferior parietal lobule. O < Y in rate of ↓ in prefrontal WM, inferior temporal cortex, hippocampus, entorhinal cortex, cerebellar hemispheres. |
Minimal change in cognition. No relationship with structural changes. |
--- | |
Rodrigue and Raz, 2004{16} |
48 | 57.6 | 26-82 | 60.4% | 16 | Physical, Cognitive, Psychological, Substance Abuse |
Brain | 5.2 years (0.2); 5.0- 5.9 years |
MRI | Manual | Volume of entorhinal cortex, hippocampus, lateral PFC [L&R] |
ICV | Verbal Memory |
↓ PFC, hippocampus, and entorhinal cortex. Rate of ↓ increased with age in PFC and hippocampus, but not entorhinal cortex. [L+R] |
↓ Entorhinal cortex = worse memory*†. |
--- | |
Walhovd et al., 2004{70} |
54 | 51 | 20-88 | 53.7% | 15.3 | Physical, Cognitive |
Cognition | 79 days (42); 42- 241 days |
MRI | Automated | Volume of WM, cortex, hippocampus [L+R] |
ICV | Verbal Memory |
↓ WM*, cortical*, hippocampal volumes* |
Bigger cortical* and hippocampal volume* = better memory*. Bigger hippocampal volume* = better memory*†. |
--- |
Key: Y = younger adults; O = older adults; GM = gray matter; WM = white matter; CSF = cerebrospinal fluid; PFC = prefrontal cortex; HF = hippocampal formation; VBM = voxel-based morphometry; ↑ = increase / positive association; ↓ = decrease / negative association; * = variable NOT measured longitudinally; † = controlling for age; [L+R] = bilateral regions combined in analyses; [L&R] = both hemispheres analyzed separately.
Note: Only statistically significant results are reported, except when otherwise noted.