Skip to main content
. 2011 Apr 12;6(4):e18788. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0018788

Table 2. Risk of Bias in Studies.

Source Intention-to-treat analysis Allocation concealment Blinding Lost to follow up
Katafuchi R 2008 [28] No Unclear Unclear No lost to follow-up
Koike M 2008[29] Yes Unsealed envelops Yes: patients and caregivers No lost to follow-up
Pozzi C 2004[30] Yes Yes Unclear No lost to follow-up
Moriyama T 2004[31] Yes Unclear No No lost to follow-up
Katafuchi R 2003[32] No Yes No Lost to follow-up: 13 patients
Shoji T 2000[33] No Yes No Lost to follow-up:2 patients
K.N.Lai 1986[34] No Unclear No No lost to follow-up
Kobayashi Y 1996[35] No Inadequate No Lost to follow-up:44 patients
Welch TR 1992[36] Unclear Yes Yes: patients and investigators Lost to follow-up:3 patients
Kobayashi Y 1988[37] No Unclear Unclear No lost to follow-up
Julian BA 1993[38] No Yes Unclear Lost to follow-up:2 patients
Uzu T 2003[39] No No Unclear No lost to follow-up
Manno C[21] Yes Yes No Lost to follow-up: 6 patients
Lv J[22] Yes Yes No Lost to follow-up: 3 patients
Locatelli F 2001[40] Yes Unclear Unclear Lost to follow-up: 12 patients