TABLE 2.
Methodological quality of trials included in the meta-analysis
Author (reference) | Year | Randomization method | Blinding | Explanation for withdrawals/dropouts | Jadad score | Allocation concealment | Intention-to-treat analysis |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Primary prophylaxis | |||||||
Pérez-Ayuso et al (12) | 2010 | Stratified randomization | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Tripathi et al (13) | 2009 | Randomization in batches of 20 patients | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Norberto et al (14) | 2007 | Computer-generated random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Lay et al (15) | 2005 | Unclear | None | Yes | 2 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Thuluvath et al (16) | 2005 | Unclear | None | Yes | 2 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Jutabha et al (17) | 2005 | A block randomization for each centre | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Psilopoulos et al (18) | 2005 | Table of random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Unclear | Yes |
Schepke et al (19) | 2004 | A block randomization for each centre | None | Yes | 3 | Central randomization | Yes |
Lo et al (20) | 2004 | Table of random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Lui et al (21) | 2002 | Randomization in batches of 18 patients | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Sarin et al (22) | 1999 | Table of random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Unclear | No |
De et al (23) | 1999 | Unclear | None | Unclear | 1 | Unclear | Yes |
Secondary prophylaxis | |||||||
Ahmad et al (24) | 2009 | Computer-generated random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | No |
Lo et al (25) | 2008 | Table of random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Romero et al (26) | 2006 | Table of random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Sarin et al (27) | 2005 | Table of random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Unclear | Yes |
Patch et al (28) | 2002 | Table of random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |
Villanueva et al (29) | 2001 | Computer-generated random numbers | None | Yes | 3 | Sealed envelopes | Yes |