Table 1.
Cross-comparison of the different algorithms. P-values for the two-tailed paired t-tests accross all subjects, all channels and all intances are shown. For the R2 coefficients, the tests were performed on the Fisher transformed values
10 trials |
30 trials |
60 trials |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
KF | SE | AF | KF | SE | AF | KF | SE | AF | |
R2 HbO | |||||||||
SE | 6e-02 | - | - | 3e-03 | - | - | 2e-07 | - | - |
AF | 2e-07 | 6e-06 | - | 1e-03 | 5e-01 | - | 4e-04 | 2e-03 | - |
GLM | 3e-15 | 2e-13 | 4e-07 | 8e-16 | 2e-12 | 4e-13 | 6e-15 | 1e-10 | 5e-14 |
R2 HbR | |||||||||
SE | 5e-05 | - | - | 2e-09 | - | - | 1e-08 | - | - |
AF | 2e-07 | 2e-03 | - | 3e-05 | 5e-03 | - | 4e-02 | 6e-10 | - |
GLM | 5e-04 | 2e-01 | 4e-01 | 7e-04 | 3e-01 | 4e-02 | 1e-04 | 6e-01 | 7e-04 |
MSE HbO | |||||||||
SE | 4e-06 | - | - | 3e-05 | - | - | 4e-06 | - | - |
AF | 2e-05 | 7e-03 | - | 1e-06 | 7e-01 | - | 2e-05 | 6e-02 | - |
GLM | 2e-12 | 2e-09 | 5e-05 | 1e-13 | 7e-11 | 1e-11 | 4e-10 | 3e-08 | 2e-09 |
MSE HbR | |||||||||
SE | 2e-05 | - | - | 4e-05 | - | - | 1e-04 | - | - |
AF | 3e-05 | 2e-01 | - | 2e-04 | 4e-03 | - | 7e-03 | 7e-05 | - |
GLM | 6e-08 | 3e-02 | 1e-02 | 3e-07 | 9e-01 | 9e-02 | 4e-06 | 1e+00 | 5e-04 |
Bold face indicates significant difference at the p < 0.05 level. KF: Kalman filter estimator, SE: Static estimator, AF: Adaptive filter, GLM: Standard GLM with 3rd order drift.