Table 1.
Trial | Population | Design | Schedule | Bisphosphonate timing | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ABCSG-12[7] | Premenopausal HR+ Stage I–III breast cancer N = 1803 |
ZA vs control | 4 mg IV every 6 mos for 3 yrs | Started at same time as endocrine therapy | HR = 0.64 for DFS in favor of ZA, p = 0.01 |
AZURE[8] | Stage II–III breast cancer N = 3360 |
ZA vs control | 4 mg IV monthly for 6 mos, then every 3 mos for 8 doses, then every 6 months for 5 doses | Neoadjuvant arm: No more than 30 days after initiation of neoadjuvant therapy Adjuvant arm: No more than 60 days since prior definitive surgery |
Accrual complete, results of neoadjuvant arm presented at SABCS 2008 |
Z-FAST ZO-FAST[9, 10] E-ZO-FAST |
HR+ Stage I–III breast cancer N = 2193 |
ZA: immediate vs delayed | 4 mg every 6 mos | Immediate arm: Started at same time as endocrine therapy Delayed arm: Started when significant BMD change or fracture |
Accrual complete, 36 month followup presented at SABCS 2008 |
NSABP-B34[12] | Stage I–II breast cancer N = 3400 |
Clodronate vs placebo | 1600 mg PO daily for 3 yrs | Randomized within 84 days of surgery | Accrual complete |
GAIN [11] | Stage II–III breast cancer N > 3000 |
Ibandronate vs control | 50 mg PO daily for 2 yrs | Accrual ongoing |
HR+ = hormone-receptor positive
SABCS = San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium
PO = per orum or by mouth
IV = intravenous