Table 2.
Characteristics of the studies included in the meta-analysis.
| Study* (ref.) | NCT/FDA-reference | Add-on to | Description of randomization | Description of allocation | Description of blinding | Reporting of drop-out | Intention-to-treat |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Albiglutide versus placebo | |||||||
| Rosenstock et al. [19] | NCT00518115 | None/Metf. | NA | NA | A | A | Yes |
|
| |||||||
| Exenatide versus placebo | |||||||
| Gill et al. [20] | NCT00516074 | Metf./TZD | NA | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Kadowaki et al. [21] | NCT00382239 | Sulfonylurea | A | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Zinman et al. [22] | NCT00099320 | TZD | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Gao et al. [23] | NCT00324363 | SU + Metf. | A | NA | A | A | Yes |
| DeFronzo et al. [24] | NCT00135330 | Rosiglitazone | A | NA | OL | A | Yes |
| Apovian et al. [25] | NR | Multiple | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Moretto et al. [26] | NCT00381342 | None | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Liutkus et al. [27] | NR | Metf/TZD + Met | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| DeFronzo et al. [28] | NCT00039013 | Metformin | A | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Buse et al. [29] | NCT00039026 | Sulfonylurea | A | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Kendall et al. [30] | NCT00035984 | SU + Metf. | NA | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Exenatide versus rosiglitazone | |||||||
| DeFronzo#et al. [24] | NCT00135330 | None | A | NA | OL | A | Yes |
| Exenatide versus glibenclamide | |||||||
| Derosa et al. [31] | NCT00135330 | None | A | NA | OL | A | Yes |
| Exenatide versus BiAsp 30/70 | |||||||
| Bergenstal et al. [32] | NCT00097877 | SU + Metf. | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
| Nauck et al. [33] | NCT00082407 | SU + Metf. | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
| Exenatide versus glargine | |||||||
| Barnett et al. [34] | NCT00099619 | SU + Metf. | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
| NCT00360334 [35] | NCT00360334 | OAD | NR | NR | OL | A | Yes |
| Heine et al. [36] | NCT00082381 | SU + Metf. | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
| Bunck et al. [37] | NCT00097500 | Metformin | A | NA | OL | A | Yes |
| Diamant et al. [38] | NCT00641056 | SU + Metf./Metf | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
| Exenatide versus insulin | |||||||
| Davis et al. [39] | NCT00099333 | SU/Metf. | NA | NA | OL | A | Yes |
|
| |||||||
| Exenatide LAR versus placebo | |||||||
| Kim et al. [40] | NCT00103935 | Metf./None | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Exenatide LAR versus pioglitazone | |||||||
| Bergenstal et al. [41] | NCT00637273 | None | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Exenatide LAR versus sitagliptin | |||||||
| Bergenstal et al. [41]# | NCT00637273 | None | A | A | A | A | Yes |
|
| |||||||
| Liraglutide versus placebo | |||||||
| Madsbad et al. [42] | FDA_1310 | None | NA | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Vilsbøll [43] | NCT00154401 | None | NA | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Seino et al. [44] | FDA_1334 | None | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Kaku et al. [45] | NCT00395746 | Sulfonylurea | NA | NA | NA | NA | Yes |
| Russell-Jones et al. [46] | NCT00331851 | SU + Metf. | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Zinman et al. [47] | NCT00333151 | Metf. + TZD | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Marre et al. [48] | NCT00318422 | Sulfonylurea | NA | NA | A | A | Yes |
| Nauck et al. [49] | NCT00318461 | Metformin | A | A | A | A | Yes |
| Liraglutide versus metformin | |||||||
| Feinglos et al. [50] | NR | None | NA | NA | NA | A | No |
|
| |||||||
| Liraglutide versus rosiglitazone | |||||||
| Marre#et al. [48] | NCT00318422 | Sulfonylurea | NA | NA | A | A | Yes |
|
| |||||||
| Liraglutide versus glimepiride | |||||||
| Madsbad#et al. [42] | NR | None | NA | NA | OL | A | Yes |
| NCT00614120 [35] | NCT00614120 | Metformin | NR | NR | OL | NR | NR |
| Nauck#et al. [49] | NCT00318461 | Metformin | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
| Garber et al. [51] | NCT00294723 | None | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
|
| |||||||
| Liraglutide versus glibenclamide | |||||||
| NCT00393718 [35] | NCT00393718 | None | NR | NR | OL | NR | NR |
|
| |||||||
| Liraglutide versus sitagliptin | |||||||
| Pratley et al. [52] | NCT00700817 | None | A | A | OL | A | Yes |
|
| |||||||
| Liraglutide versus glargine | |||||||
| Russell-Jones#et al. [46] | NCT00331851 | SU + Metf. | A | A | A | A | Yes |
*All the studies are multicenter and designed as parallel series, with the exception of NCT00099619 which is a cross-over trial; #studies with multiple comparators. Metf.: metformin; NA: not adequate or not adequately reported; A: adequate; TZD: thiazolidinediones; TZD + Met.: thiazolidinediones + metformin; SU + Metf.: sulfonylureas and metformin; OL: open-label; OAD: oral antidiabetic drugs; NR: not reported; SU/Metf: sulfonylureas or metformin; LAR: long-acting release.