Table 1.
Parent virus | Key properties of wild-type virus | Advantages | Disadvantages | Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|
Adenovirus | Double stranded DNA genome, ~ 35Kb | Straightforward production of recombinant vectors at high titers | Inflammatory and antigenic | Various generations with increasingly deleted genomes “Gutted” vectors have no viral coding sequences and large carrying capacity but are difficult to produce. |
Non-enveloped | Transduces non-dividing cells | Tropism can be modified by altering coat proteins | ||
Over 50 serotypes | Wide choice of serotypes | |||
~ 100nm in size | ||||
Genome remains episomal in infected cells | ||||
Herpes simplex virus | Double stranded DNA genome, ~ 150 Kb | Transduces non-dividing cells | Complex genome -Difficult to produce recombinant virus | HSV 1 and 2 most widely used as vectors. Herpes family includes Epstein Barr virus, CMV, etc |
Enveloped | Very efficient transduction of dividing and non-dividing cells | Cytotoxicity | ||
~ 200nm in size | Has a natural latency in neurons | |||
Genome remains episomal in infected cells | Very large carrying capacity | |||
Adeno-associated virus | Single-stranded DNA genome, 4.8 Kb | Perceived to be safe (w.t. virus causes no known disease) | Difficult to produce | W.t. virus cannot replicate without helper virus |
Non-enveloped | Transduces non-dividing cells | Carrying capacity is insufficient for certain applications | W.t. virus integrates in a site-specific manner; recombinant virus remains as a stable, concatameric plasmid | |
Growing number of serotypes identified | Thought to have low immunogenicity, but this is being re-evaluated | Transduction efficiency sometimes low | Limitations of single stranded genome now overcome by development of double copy (self complementary) DNA viruses | |
~20 nm in size | ||||
Oncoretrovirus | RNA genome ~ 8–10 Kb | Straightforward production of recombinant vectors at moderate titers | Require host cell division | Usually used ex vivo |
Enveloped | Pseudotyped vectors have wide host range | Risk of insertional mutagenesis | 2 genomes per virion, reverse transcribed into DNA | |
~100nm in size | ||||
Lentivirus | RNA genome ~ 8–10 Kb | Straightforward production of recombinant vectors at moderate titers | Risk of insertional mutagenesis, but non-integrating vectors being developed | 2 genomes per virion, reverse transcribed into DNA |
Enveloped | Pseudotyped vectors have wide host range and are often very efficient | |||
~100nm in size | Transduces non-dividing cells |
Reproduced from reference [21] with permission