Skip to main content
. 2011 May 12;8(5):1503–1519. doi: 10.3390/ijerph8051503

Table 7.

Summary of results to evaluate the causal association between SHS and dental caries.

Tooth type Element Description for consistency (number of study) Evidence synthesis according to study quality Perceived shortcoming Evidence synthesis
Deciduous tooth Strength of association Strong (2), moderate (5), weak and moderate (2), weak (1), no association (1) Moderate to strong evidence for weak to moderate association There was no control group in current smokers in natural experiment. Possible evidence
Natural experiment Smaller effect size and no association (3) in previous exposure group Strong evidence for natural experiment Natural experiment and dose-response relationship were reported from two countries. Cohort study was not conducted.
Dose-response relationship Obvious relationship between level of exposure and the effect size (5) Strong evidence for dose-response relationship.

Permanent tooth Strength of association Moderate (1), weak (5 a), and no association (2) Moderate evidence for weak association Only one study reported results of natural experiment and dose-response relationship. Insufficient evidence
Natural experiment Effect size was similar in previous and current exposure groups (1) Limited evidence for natural experiment
Dose-response relationship Relationship between level of exposure and the effect size was not clear (1) Limited evidence for natural experiment
a

one study with cohort format.